Saturday, May 11, 2013

Neutering Marriage is Not a Conservative Position

 blogs "Hey gay people! you're being used".

And it's not about rights, either the rights of gay people to get "married" (according to the new definition) or about the rights of religious people to "freedom of worship".

It's about the state increasing its power.

"The central problem with the gay marriage agenda is not that at some point in the future an unwilling man of the cloth might be strongarmed into giving his blessing to a gay union, but rather that it allows the state to do something that was traditionally considered beyond its purview…

Some have sought to depict the drive for gay marriage as a continuation of the struggle for civil rights that exploded in the mid-twentieth century; it’s better understood as a continuation, and intensification, of the modern state’s desire to get a foot in the door of our private lives and to assume sovereignty over our relationships."

More here, here, and here.
Expanding government intrusion into personal relationships and families is not a good thing.

Friday, May 10, 2013

Elizabeth Warren Can’t See the Forest Through the Trees Planted by Capitalists

Elizabeth Warren certainly is popular with my Leftist connections on Facebook. They proudly copy and pasted her comments:
I hear all this, you know, 'Well, this is class warfare, this is whatever. No.

Yes, it is class warfare to target the "rich" – by definition.
There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own -- nobody.

Well, no, there isn't, because someone else has to buy the good and services provided by the rich. The fact is, nobody really does ANYTHING on their own, but we still need to have boundaries. There still needs to be some level of personal autonomy, private property and ownership, and personal responsibility. Should Warren be elected to Senate, she will not have done it on her own, yet she will not be forced to let more than a third of her votes be cast by someone else.
You built a factory out there? Good for you. But I want to be clear. You moved your goods to market on the roads the rest of us paid for.

The rich paid for those roads, too. All of us - who buy gas, anyway - paid for those roads, all of us can use them. Even the people who don't buy gas.
You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate.

Property owners, a group which definitely includes the rich, paid to educate them. But I'm for separation of state and school anyway.
You were safe in your factory because of police-forces and fire-forces that the rest of us paid for.

Again, the rich pay for them, too – more so than other people.
You didn't have to worry that marauding bands would come and seize everything at your factory -- and hire someone to protect against this -- because of the work the rest of us did.

Uh, is there a factory that doesn't have private security?
Now look, you built a factory and it turned into something terrific, or a great idea. God bless -- keep a big hunk of it. But part of the underlying social contract is, you take a hunk of that and pay forward for the next kid who comes along.

And why does that have to be through the hands of D.C. politicians? Who is it that is funding charities, anyway?

No doubt unwittingly, Elizabeth Warren actually makes our point for us – that by letting free markets work, people who build wealth employ other people to mutual benefit. The wealthy got wealthy, in part, through providing jobs.

The people the wealthy hired were compensated as agreed. The customers who bought the goods or services provided by the wealthy were given that for which they paid. Now, people like Warren want to ignore the fact that the mutual, voluntary transactions were completed and use government force to make the wealthy pay more not only to those already compensated for their work, but to uninvolved people who refuse to work at all.

Are we to believe that someone who studied hard and stayed clean and involved through high school, college, and medical school to become a doctor and works long and odd hours saving lives and then practices good financial habits has less right to enjoy the fruits of her labors and risks than someone who goofed off, dropped out, abused substances, caused trouble, watches the clock at his entry-level job to make sure that he never appears to be working a minute more than 40 hours per week (minus breaks), and blows his money?

All of the things Warren lists have been available to all. It is the wealthy that used them in ways valued most by society.

You can find some good responses to Warren here, here, and here.

Monday, May 6, 2013

A Test For Marriage Neutering Advocates

Rhode Island became the most recent state to neuter its marriage licensing.

Rhode Island has no existing laws whatsoever against consensual incest.

Based on these facts (and you can check them out for yourself if you don't believe me) I'd like to know from marriage neutering advocates what their reaction would be to this situation:

Two unmarried women approach the counter at the appropriate government office in Rhode Island and ask for a license, saying "We very much want to get married." They have been living together for many years now, and are raising two children together. The clerk examines the paperwork and realizes that the women share a biological father, who has never been in either's life. As it turns out, the women were not raised together and only met for the first time as adults.

Should the law instruct the clerk to issue them a state-recognized license, entitling them to all of the legal aspects of marriage?

If not, why not? Is it Constitutional to deny them a license?

Remember, their relationship is not criminal in any way.

Saturday, May 4, 2013

Greg Koukl on Secular Religious Division of Marriage

Greg Koukl of Stand to Reason on "Can Marriage Be Divided into Secular and Religious Institutions?"

The Left and Moral Equivalence

I like getting the perspective of Tammy Bruce and her friends. Tammy has been a voice for audio content for a long time. She also writes books and columns, blogs, and appeared on cable news as a talking head. Shifra blogged on Tammy's site something called "Liberals and Moral Equivalence".
First, some definitions of terms, as “moral relativism” and “moral equivalence,” are, it seems, sometimes used interchangeably. But, while related, they are, in fact, different.

“Moral relativism” refers to the notion that, in our diverse, multicultural world, no one culture is better than another culture, so that no judgments can be made about a specific culture.

For example:

In the U.S.A., a day off may be spent having a picnic with family and friends, enjoying a barbecue, tossing a Frisbee, or maybe catching a ball game, while, in some Islamic countries, a day off might entail having the village gather to watch a woman being shoved waist-deep into a hole in the ground, while everyone throws boulders until she is stoned to death, all because she is suspected of having committed adultery.

See? Different strokes for different folks.

In The New Thought Police, Tammy wrote about the danger of such a world-view:
Multiculturalism is not about exotic restaurants and charming street fairs. It is a code word for moral relativism. Accepting the notion that all ideas and systems are equal precludes a willingness to think critically about what surrounds us. It is the cornerstone of our inability to come to judgments about events…. (p. 150)
Moral equivalence, on the other hand, is a deceptive device used by Liberals to “prove” their points by taking the focus away from the obvious evil, and focusing on what they  perceive to be the more “immediate problem.”
Go read her examples of moral equivalence.

Leftists do not have to be consistent or coherent, have priorities or perspective, because their whole way of looking at things is based on feeling and emotion.

Also, a question I like to ask partisans is, "If the other party's guy/gal did what you party's guy/gal just did, would you think that is OK?" I'm not necessarily talking about taking a position, but about the principles or actions. For example, is filibustering OK or not? That sort of thing.

Friday, May 3, 2013

David Russell Explains Marriage Defense Well

David Russell writes at The Poached Egg on his case for marriage. He touches upon what's going on in Christian circles:
One Man One Woman
We live in a culture where sensationalism wins the day and scriptural illiteracy runs rampant in the pews. To assume Christ would change his mind undermines the truth of his divinity and if the apostles got it wrong the inerrant word of God is no longer inerrant or it is basically ignored. The scriptures couldn't be more true when it says, "My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge." (Hosea 4:6)


 
One need not be Christian to see that marriage unites the sexes, but any follow of Christ should not deny what He affirmed. Then Russell moves on to the larger issue of society:
 
Civil rights is not the issue. There is no discrimination except in basic behavior, which all laws are based around. The truth is, we are all entitled to marry in the same way, we all share the same rights and restrictions equally. I am a heterosexual male and have the same right to marry as the homosexual, I also have the same restrictions the homosexual has. Greg Koukl gives a beautiful illustration in a past issue of solid ground, he puts it like this, “Smith and Jones both qualify to vote in America where they are citizens. Neither are allowed to vote in France. Jones, however has no interest in U.S. politics, he's partial to European concerns. Would Jones have a case if he complained?" Simply put NO! both he and Smith have the same rights to vote in America Smith chooses to exercise that right, so for Jones there is only inequality in desire not in legality. 
Basically, the marriage law applies to each citizen in exactly the same way, the Homosexual wants the right to do something neither person can do. So all those with equal signs posted to their profiles are drastically misinformed, or they simply like being part of the crowd.
Right. Heterosexuals and homosexuals have EQUAL rights now, and they would still have them under neutered licensing. This is not about equality, but that word is a useful emotional hook.

Natural marriage produces the next generation, the government has a vested interest in the next generation, so, naturally it promotes the carrying on of the civilization. The government needs to be somewhat involved in this process due to the behavior of humans and their inability to commit. Also, imagine what a man would do if there was no accountability, he could leave and bear no responsibility to his mate or children; the government makes sure the women and children are protected. The government doesn't get involved because you're in love, it reigns in that aspect of commitment and furthermore, deals with inheritance intrinsic to natural marriage, It also provides relief to promote the family in regard to the very nature of child rearing, something also inherent to natural marriage. Tax relief is given to lighten the load for fathers who have out of work mothers and children you now have to feed.
That is a excellent way of boiling down the truth of the matter.

With examining the benefits of natural marriage, why do I think it should be the only one promoted by government? First, it is the natural foundation of society and yields benefits to everyone, no other relationship can do that. Second, a study by J.D. Unwin concludes out of eighty six civilizations spanning the course of five thousand years the most prosperous were the ones with a strong marriage ethic, he includes that every civilization that abandoned this ethic and liberalized their sexual practices experienced demise not long after. (Joseph Unwin, Sex and Culture: London Oxford press, 1934)
I'm sure some Leftist has written a response to that work by now that blames economic inequality for the demise of those civilizations.

Is Jesus a Republican?

My short answer is "no".

But he certainly isn't a Democrat, either.

The GOP is a U.S. political party, and as such, is a man-made organization, the main purpose of which is to get members elected and appointed to government offices. It is a flawed organization founded and comprised of flawed people.

I do believe, though, that conservatism can be consistent with Christian principles, and in fact I maintain that my own conservatism is consistent with my Christian worldview. And, in the U.S., it is the GOP that is a home to the conservative movement and is one of the two dominant, effective political parties, hence my support for the GOP.

In an ideal situation, the perfect form of government is a benevolent dictatorship - an absolute monarchy, actually – with the monarch being eternal, unchanging, unequaled, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, holy, loving, merciful, and just. (That’s God, to those of you who are slow on the uptake.) But since He has given us the freedom to govern ourselves for now, and we are a mix of unrepentant sinners and repentant-but-still-unperfected sinners, I do not believe there is a better governmental system than the brilliant one devised by our mostly Christian-influenced founders – our union of states in a capitalist, constitutional, democratic, representative, republic with separation of powers and checks and balances.

It is that system that recognizes that people will generally look out for their own self-interests and in doing so will cooperate where mutually beneficial, and will also engage voluntarily in private charity. It is that system that recognizes that since sin has marred each of us, none of us should have too much power. It is that system that recognizes that people will do wrong, and some of those wrongs demand a collective response from the people as a whole. So, it is a system that understands that true nature of people.

This is a system worth conserving.  Hence - conservatism.

Conservatism generally (if not all individual conservatives) promotes respect for human life; defending and esteeming marriage; respect for authority; personal freedom, responsibility and accountability; punishment and restitution for wrongs; private charity; and encourages acknowledging God in all areas of life. These are all very much part of what Jesus taught and affirmed.

Leftists, including some Democrats, cite God as Creator and Jesus' acceptance of prostitutes and others marginalized by society during his earthly ministry, His message of forgiveness, His "cast the first stone" and "take the plank out of your own eye" statements, His commands to take care of the needy, His "turn the other cheek" statement, and His willingness to be beaten and crucified as examples of why Republicans and conservatives are wrong and why Christians should support Democrats in their efforts to:

-expand government social spending (including allowing illegal aliens to come here, stay here, and receive such spending)

-socialize health care

-implement "environmental protection" legislation that is really about forced wealth transfer and infringing on private property rights

-promote pacifism

-promote licentiousness, especially in sexual behavior

Such applications take Jesus' words and actions out of context and twist His words.

It is bizarre to me that people who so stridently promote and defend philosophical naturalism (claiming that we and everything else in the universe are the products of nothing more than natural processes alone) appeal to our belief in a Creator to promote their "environmental protection" agenda. Many of these people are the same people that see nothing wrong with dismembering babies in the womb. Many of the same people who promote government-funded (meaning taxpayer-funded) health care for seniors by appealing to our compassion would just as soon put our seniors to death, claiming it is for dignity and pain-relief, but in actuality because the seniors would become an expensive inconvenience.

Yes, Jesus accepted and forgave people who admitted and repented of their sins. You can't repent of sins if you don't recognize them as sins in the first place. The phrase "Go and sin no more" comes to mind. He saved their souls but did not necessarily protect them from the earthly consequences of their sins. The repentant thief on the cross comes to mind – Jesus told him "Today, you will be with me in Paradise," indicating he was forgiven, but Jesus didn't use His power to remove the man from the cross and stave off death.  And yes, people should take the plank out of their own eye before trying to remove the speck in someone else's eye, and if you have repented of your sins and turned to Jesus, then the plank has been removed.

He'll judge the world in the future, but Jesus certainly wasn't "nonjudgmental" during His earthly ministry.  According to the written accounts of His teachings, He talked a lot about Hell and had some choice words in public for certain people, and don't forget what He did to the money changers.

Jesus ordered His followers to take care of the poor, not the government. He didn't advocate stealing from the rich to "care for the poor".  He told a rich man to sell everything he had and give it to the poor himself, not to sell all he had and give it to Rome for redistribution.

Jesus did not teach pacifism, either.  As Greg Koukl points out, "turning the other cheek" likely refers to dealing with insults. Jesus sent His disciples out with swords. I'd agree that Jesus would be against using force unjustly, but not all use of force is unjust.

(Oh - and despite what PETA would say, Jesus was not a vegetarian, either.)

I'd like to note that nowhere does Jesus command us to spread Christianity by force. He commanded us to make disciples, true, but everything about His earthly ministry teaches us to make disciples by preaching the Gospel through our words and living the Gospel in our actions. Promote clean living. Care for those in need, including telling them when, where, and how their sins are causing their problems (IF their own sins are causing those particular problems).

So, while I wouldn't say that Jesus is a Republican, I would say that being a Republican is entirely compatible with being a Christian. Being a Christian is much more than just being involved in politics, however. It also includes living a moral life and giving of your time, talent, and treasure to those who need it. We can't insist that the government get out of social spending and then not pick up the slack ourselves by tending to the legitimate needs of others. That is all part of having a relationship with Christ as your Lord and Savior.

Sunday, April 28, 2013

The Bush Legacy

I wrote on January 20, 2009:

= = =
It is impossible to write a definitive judgment on the legacy of President George W. Bush at this time, although there have been many evaluations and retrospectives in the last several months.

Left-leaning folks, especially those who have had Bush Derangement Syndrome from the moment the first chad dangled, will try to blame him as much as possible while denying him as much credit as they can, and some Republicans will defend Bush's every move, even if they would have pitched a fit if it had been done by a Democrat.

We should be vigilant against those who would try to write him into history as the worst President ever. They will try to do so for political expediency, since he is the most recent Republican to serve in that office, and the only President besides Obama that most newer voters will remember with any understanding.

We should also be careful not to let Bush's decisions or tolerations that were decidedly expansive of government be portrayed as proof that limiting government doesn't work.


Friday, April 26, 2013

New Page Added on Comment Policy

Read all about it. It is short.

Yes, Neutering Marriage Affects All

The Aquila Report has something written by John Barber, "Ten Reasons Why SSM Affects Your Marriage".
4. Same-sex marriage will absorb your marriage into a new view of reality
The basic argument for same-sex marriage states that there is no fundamental difference between the rights of gays/lesbians and heterosexuals to marry. Supporting the legal claim of “gender equality” is a view of human sexuality that erodes natural, gender-specific, differences between men and woman. The result is a “unisexual” view of personhood which, rather than affirm diversity, blurs it beyond recognition. The unisexual view of personhood is part of global move toward a hermaphroditic understanding of reality... Ironically, diversity, the very thing secularism claims to champion, is what it destroys. Unity (two people becoming one) and diversity (a husband and a wife) are held in perfect balance in traditional marriage.

This is something many people refuse to admit when discussing this with those who oppose the neutering of marriage. They present it as all about a particular couple they know, if not themselves. However, laws apply to all, and what our laws says inevitably sends a message about our values and priorities. All laws express someone's morality. If the law says that brideless and groomless coupling is an equal action to marriage, then marriage can't, as an institution, be about the needs of children and the gender inclusion or sex integration can't be valuable, because it is indistinguishable from gender exclusion or sex segregation. (You might think this will clear the way again for male-only clubs to exist, but a judge who thinks along the lines of a marriage neutering advocate would rule that a woman is a male if she says she is, and thus must be admitted, or that since there is no difference between men and women, women can't be excluded.)

7.  Same-sex marriage defeats the purpose of the state’s interest in benefiting your marriage
A reason the federal government bestows numerous benefits on families with children, including child tax credits, is due to their social significance. The intent and design of heterosexual marriage is to provide the normal and stable conditions for the birth and upbringing of children. Homosexual marriage is not aimed at providing such conditions. Its chief purpose is the personal gratification of two individuals whose relationship is inherently barren. A major agenda item of gay activists is to secure a range of federal, state, and local benefits, hitherto enjoyed by traditional marriages. Should that goal be met fully, courts would only serve to empty traditional marriage of its significant social meaning, other than the respect of personal preferences. Should that ensue, would the federal government (especially one burdened economically) still see the necessity to continue to extend tax breaks to married heterosexual couples with children? Child tax credits could be offered to gay/lesbian couples who adopt. But the government could also choose to “level the playing field” by maintaining deductions for dependents whether they are children or spouses.
The ultimate goal of Leftists is to remove marriage from the law. That's why "get the government out of marriage" is a false compromise. Some Leftists, including homosexual Leftists, admit their goal is to remove marriage from the law. The see unfairness in married people and/or adults with minor children getting any advantage, reward, or assistance over unmarried people or childless adults. Many libertarians agree. Many conservatives, however, note that in order to conserve society, we need new citizens, preferably raised in stable, loving homes that provide them a role model and parents of each of the two sexes with whom they will have to interact with as adults.
9.  The redistribution of marriage rights modifies your marriage as a natural entity afforded legal recognition
Marriage is a naturally occurring relationship. A purpose of U.S. law is to create a flourishing context for the family to govern itself. Put differently, the state does not create marriage but is to create complimentary environments in which martial life is legally recognized and protected. Redefining marriage by legal fiat changes this point of reference. It shifts the legal posture of the state from recognizing a preexisting institution to creating the institution after its own image and likeness. The state would become the originator of your marriage. Case in point, the Hawaii Supreme Court called marriage “a state conferred legal partnership status.” Baehr v. Lewin, 852 P.2d 44, 58 (Haw. 1993).
Do our rights come from Nature's God or do they come from the bench?

You can also see what we wrote about harms at The Opine Editorials.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Defending Marriage From Neutering is Not Hateful

Discussions with marriage neutering advocates continued on Twitter. Here's where I wrote about this before. This all started because I tweeted a link to a column by Matt Barber pointing out that the State of Washington was attacking a florist because she didn't want to be associated with a groomless "wedding".

Paul continued with bumper sticker slogans, tautologies, name-calling and displays a lack of reading comprehension. He still hasn't explained why we should neuter marriage.

Pauls_View ‏@pauls_view

@PlayfulWalrus There is no reason allowing gays to marry will have ANY effect on straight marriage.
Neutering marriage dilutes it. Counterfeiting devalues the authentic. Marriage laws are part of public policy and apply to all. Neutering marriage changes the very meaning of marriage, and sends a clear message that, from a societal perspective, marriage is about the whims of two adults, not what is of most concern to society, and not about orgnizating and perpetuating society. Why does the the state care if two people love each other, or have the hots for each other?

Public policy about marriage, parenting, and family has an effect on all of us. State marriage licenses are issued on behalf of the people of a state. They are not a private matter. Same-sex couples are free to have ceremonies, share names, share homes, share beds, share a life, etc. But they should not be able to force the rest of us to neuter marriage licensing.
Gays are couples now without = rights
Individuals have rights. On what basis do we treat any TWO people equally? If they DO the same thing. Sex-segregated relationships are not equal to bride+groom relationships, and so there is no obligation to treat them equally.

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Affirming Marriage Is Not Hateful

In July of 2008, the Pink Lady (known to some as the Los Angeles Times, tried to convince readers that Proposition 8 was doomed at the ballot box. Of course, it went on to be approved in November that year, adding the California Marriage Amendment to the state constitution.

The Los Angeles Times tried to convince us that since what they see as the "in-crowd" supports marriage neutering and that those of us who honor the bride+groom construct should give up. Staff writers Jessica Garrison and Dan Morain reported. [NOTE: They now have a paywall, so free clicks are limited.]
A bare majority of California voters would continue to allow gay marriage, according to a new poll released Friday.
Yet again, that was extremely sloppy language used. Proposition 8 RESTORED bride-groom marriage licensing to the State of California. "Gay marriage" was not banned (and neither were round squares). Anyone, regardless of sexual orientation, could "marry" someone of the same sex in ceremonies, form legal partnerships, commit to each other, live with each other, etc. Passing Proposition 8 did not send the Gestapo (or, as one dispicable ad depicted, Mormon missionairies) into Metropolitan churches and homes and banquet halls to break up "gay marriages".

Friday, April 19, 2013

The Right to Vote

In early 2009, there was an entry on the Los Angeles Times blog [NOTE: The Pink Lady now has a paywall, that last I checked, kicked in after so many hits from you per month] about the LDS church contributions supporting the California Marriage Amendment. Of course, the entry prompted a bunch of the usual comments.  I'm picking out one to analyze here.
"scotch9" wrote on January 31, 2009 at 03:22 PM:

It would seem that the right wing conseravtive movement wants America to adopt a Middle easrten Style Government where religion dictates the thoughts and actions of people.
Not all right wing conservatives are traditionally religious. But I think he means the "religious right", and no, major personalities in the religious right do NOT want a theocracy. Actually, they (the Christian ones, anyway) await a benevolent dictatorship with the return of Christ, but until then they champion the Constitution.
For 233 years we have fought aganst this all around the world.
No, we haven't. We have fought tyranny in various ways, and that the California Supreme Court did by ordering the neutering of marriage licenses was tyrannical.
I know some are uncomfortable with same sex relationships. So what.
That's not the issue here (although you think state-issued marriage licenses mean affirmation). The issue here is who gets to decide state licensing requirements? A handful of people, or the voting citizenry?
The writer then goes on to compare present-day conservatives with Tories from the time of the American Revolution, defenders of American slavery, opponents of women's suffrage, segregationists, and Jim Crow proponents, before going on to this gem:

We were even attacked on Septemeber 11, 2001 by right wing conservative religious types screaming glory to the god they say is suprior to the God these American Chistains rage for, and they say,makes them superior to gay persons. These poeple seek to devide, inspire violence, murder, hate and create evil.
The hijackers were all male, too, so I guess all men are just like them.
They know all about all, just ask them.
Well if you aren't confident that you know anything, then why should anyone else listen to your opinion?

It is entirely possible that "conservatives" have been wrong on many things, but are right about this thing.

This is what people like me want: Limited, constitutional government. I don't want to come into your home using the force of law and tell you how to live. But that also means you can't come to me and take something from me without my approval. So if you want to live with someone of the same sex, exchange vows and jewelry and names with them, have a party, go on vacation together, and all of that, you are free to do so.  But when you march on down to a building that is paid for by the taxpayers, and ask a public servant to issue you a state marriage license on behalf of the people of California, then the people of California, including me, have a right to say "no" if you don't meet the requirements, as long as the requirements are clear and applied equally. And that's exactly what we do. Men and women can get marriage licenses, regardless of sexual orientation. Women are not excluded. Homosexuals are not excluded.

I also have the right to practice my religion and vote as I choose.

California Domestic Partnership Law Proves Our Point

I noticed back in November 2008 that still hasn't been addressed in the discussion over then neutering of marriage, especially as it relates to California's Marriage Amendment. As I've written numerous times, California already treats domestic partners as spouses.
But notice that such domestic partnerships are only available to same-sex couples, and not offered to both-sexes couples unless one of the individuals is over a certain age.

Where have all these "equality" activists been when it comes to such "inequality"?  They keep telling us that domestic partnerships are not the same as marriage, that the word marriage carries with it certain things – which might precisely be why a both-sexes couple might prefer to get a domestic partnership instead of a licensed marriage.

That domestic partnership law proves that state policy includes treating different kinds of relationships differently.
I don’t see how the California Supreme Court could order the neutering of marriage licensing without also ordering that domestic partnerships be offered to both-sexes couples whose members are of any adult age. Perhaps all domestic partnerships should be immediately dissolved?

Unless you have been calling for domestic partnerships to be opened to both-sexes couples, you have less credibility if you are now insisting on marriage neutering under the guise of "equality"

At the time I first wrote about this, I said I actually like the domestic partnership law, by the way, and do not want to see domestic partnerships dissolved. However, seeing has how they are used as Trojan Horses to neuter marriage licensing by court, I have since told people in other states they should oppose them. The very people who push for domestic partnership laws turn right around after they pass and call them insults.


Defending Your Support of Marriage

Are you being criticized for your defense of marriage, and state licenses requiring both a bride and a groom, rather than excluding women or excluding men? Maybe friends, family, bosses, customers, coworkers, social networking contacts, bloggers, and commenters have lashed out and you or pressured you?  Maybe you have received angry calls from strangers that you perceived as threatening bodily harm to you, but in retrospect, you realize that the person calling you willingly subjects himself to the described treatment for jollies? Have you been called a hater or a bigot?
Well, I think I have a solution.

Feel free to copy and paste this defense I am providing below.  You don’t even have to give me credit.  Just be sure to modify it so your critic's name appears in the salutation. Modify as necessary to be relevant to your circumstances. I refer to California Proposition 8, for example.


Shall We Vote on Your Marriage Now?

That, or some variation of that, was used by some protestors against California's marriage amendment, voted in as Proposition 8, and has been used ever since in the USA and around the world regarding disputes about neutering marriage. It is used by demonstrators in person and online and in print.
They are trying to stir sympathy, asking you to place yourself in their shoes. But what is the logical argument, if any, being made? It seems to be "You voted against licensing my relationship as marriage, and that hurts because I want my relationship to be licensed as marriage."

I'm sure I’ll be corrected if I am wrong.

We've all wanted something, at sometime in our lives, that was wrong, or that wasn't ours to have, or wasn't even possible. That we want something doesn't mean we have a right to have it. It still isn't a right even if a bunch of us want it. It still isn't a right even if a court one day says it is. Wanting something doesn't mean it is right that you get it, or that any means used to get it are right.

Marriage has existed for all of human history. Our state, our current governments, did not create it. It recognizes it and has chosen to license it. There is a reason that the state is involved in marriage licensing, and it isn't because anyone has a right to a marriage license. It isn't so that the state can reward two people for finding love, mutual attraction, or good times together. There is a reason marriage throughout history has united the sexes, and that state licensing of marriage has reflected that.

And those reasons have nothing to do with stopping anyone from engaging in same-sex partnering or physical activity, or punishing people for having same-sex attractions, or trying to make such people feel bad. It does not prevent same-sex couples from living together, committing to each other, forming legal relationships, or considering themselves married or being treated by others as married.

As I've said many times, there is no right to a state-issued license against the demonstrated will of the state voters. True rights do not obligate others without their consent, unless a crime has been committed. When you ask someone (the people of California, for example) for something (a marriage license), they have the right to say "no".  We have the freedom of speech. It is even enumerated in the Constitution. But I do not have a right to force you to read this blog or listen to what I have to say – because that would obligate you without your consent.

Marriage defenders are not the people who took this matter to the courts. In doing so, same-sex partners were already subjecting their marriages to a vote – a vote by the judges. Since our government rules through the consent of the governed, marriage licensing stipulations fall under our authority. Even with equal access/protection and nondiscrimination laws, there is no compelling reason for a court to force neutered marriage licensing, because there is equal access to traditional marriage licenses for both men and women of any sexual orientation. That someone does not want to get that license under current terms does not compel a change. That I prefer to grow and eat vegetables instead of fish does not mean that something is wrong with fishing licenses, even if people will mount large catches on their wall and receive praise, while nobody cares as much that I grow tasty vegetables.
Now given that marriage licensing is up to the people of the state, what about that original question?  What if people voted to change marriage licensing so that only same-sex couples could get them?  I wouldn't be happy about it, but it wouldn't stop me from being married to my wife. I would still be happy with her, I would still live my life married to her, whether or not the state licensed it. That is because my marriage is based on biological fact and it is part of a historical tradition and is about our commitment to each other before God.

There is nothing stopping anyone from circulating a petition to change marriage licensing in such a way. So far, there has been ONE state where someone neutered marriage licensing by circulating a petition to get in on on the ballot, getting it on the ballot, and the voters approving it. So if they get enough signatures, it will get on the ballot. If the ballot measure gets enough votes, it will pass.  So if you want to vote on my marriage, I say... go for it. My happiness does not depend on what you think of my marriage.


When Marriage Neutering Proponents Say Love is Love

"Love is love."  That is one of those bumber-sticker tautologies used in an emotional appeal by marriage neutering advocates.

Well, of course X = X.  But what is the logical argument, if any, implied?  It seems to be "The love I have for my same-sex partner is no different than the love you have for your opposite-sex partner, therefore, our relationship should be licensed by the state as marriage just as yours can be."

I'm sure I'll be corrected if I am wrong.

I first heard "Love is love" in response to California Proposition 8, which was adopted by the voters and became the California Marriage Amendment, part of the state constitution.

First of all, California law deals with "love" exactly twice[1].  In neither case is marriage or domestic partnerships addressed.  There is no legal requirement that spouses or domestic partners actually love each other.  You can get a marriage license or a domestic partnership with someone you loathe.  I don’t advise it, but it is legally possible.

Biblical promises that Jesus loves us aside, none of us can really be sure whether or not one person loves another person.  In some cases, we can make a good guess based on our experiences with how they treat each other.  The people at the county office who issue marriage licenses are unlikely to be able to objectively prove whether or not you love the person with whom you are getting the marriage license.  Fortunately, they don't ask.

It also strikes me that if you're going to use "love is love" as an argument to change the legal definition of marriage, you should also have a legal definition of love in state law, as "love" means different things to different people.  We don't have a definition of love in state law.  But that is okay, because we don't base public policy on whether or not any two adults love each other.

If we were to accept the implied argument, wouldn't that mean that any relationship where love is claimed should be licensed as marriage if requested?  After all, if love is love, then that means that platonic friends who love each other should be able to be married to one another as far as state licensing, no matter how many there are.  Close family members (even without incest), or people carrying on an extramarital affair, or people who regularly engage in group sex with each other - all should be able to claim state marriage licenses for their relationships, no?

Also, how does anyone know for sure if the love in one relationship (say, bride+groom) is equivalent to another (say, same-sex partners), especially if they've only ever engaged in one kind?

"Love is love" can't be the basis for state marriage licensing if we are going to keep any order.  Fortunately, licensing is based on objective facts that are a matter of public record: one adult (or emancipated) female and one adult (or emancipated male), neither one currently in a licensed marriage, who are not closely related.  There's no requirement or restriction involving love or sexual orientation.

Ultimately, since state marriage licensing is not about love, the argument is irrelevant.


[1] California Government Code section 421.7.
"I Love You, California," a song published in 1913 with lyrics by F.B. Silverwood and music by A.F. Frankenstein, is an official state song.


Insurance Code:
 Section 10110.  Every person has an insurable interest in the life and health of:
   (a) Himself.
   (b) Any person on whom he depends wholly or in part for education or support.
   (c) Any person under a legal obligation to him for the payment of money or respecting property or services, of which death or illness might delay or prevent the performance.
   (d) Any person upon whose life any estate or interest vested in him depends.

10110.1.  (a) An insurable interest, with reference to life and disability insurance, is an interest based upon a reasonable expectation of pecuniary advantage through the continued life, health, or bodily safety of another person and consequent loss by reason of that person's death or disability or a substantial interest engendered by love and affection in the case of individuals closely related by blood or law.
   (b) An individual has an unlimited insurable interest in his or her own life, health, and bodily safety and may lawfully take out a policy of insurance on his or her own life, health, or bodily safety and have the policy made payable to whomsoever he or she pleases, regardless of whether the beneficiary designated has an insurableinterest.
   (c) Except as provided in Section 10110.4, an employer has an insurable interest, as referred to in subdivision (a), in the life or physical or mental ability of any of its directors, officers, or employees or the directors, officers, or employees of any of its subsidiaries or any other person whose death or physical or mental disability might cause financial loss to the employer; or, pursuant to any contractual arrangement with any shareholder concerning the reacquisition of shares owned by the shareholder at the time of his or her death or disability, on the life or physical or mental ability of that shareholder for the purpose of carrying out the contractual arrangement; or, pursuant to any contract obligating the employer as part of compensation arrangements or pursuant to a contract obligating the employer as guarantor or surety, on the life of the principal obligor.  The trustee of an employer or trustee of a pension, welfare benefit plan, or trust established by an employer providing life, health, disability, retirement, or similar benefits to employees and retired employees of the employer or its affiliates and acting in a fiduciary capacity with respect to those employees, retired employees, or their dependents or beneficiaries has an insurable interest in the lives of employees and retired employees for whom those benefits are to be provided.  The employer shall obtain the written consent of the individual being insured.
   (d) An insurable interest shall be required to exist at the time the contract of life or disability insurance becomes effective, but need not exist at the time the loss occurs.
   (e) Any contract of life or disability insurance procured or caused to be procured upon another individual is void unless the person applying for the insurance has an insurable interest in the individual insured at the time of the application.
   (f) Notwithstanding subdivisions (a), (d), and (e), a charitable organization that meets the requirements of Section 214 or 23701d of the Revenue and Taxation Code may effectuate life or disability insurance on an insured who consents to the issuance of that insurance.
   (g) This section shall not be interpreted to define all instances in which an insurable interest exists.


Thursday, April 18, 2013

Name Calling and Bible Bashing

Paul has elected to contiue the discussion.

Pauls_View  @pauls_view 
@PlayfulWalrus I have to take up bloggoing. It's unrealistic to reply to your pages of rhetoric with 140 chars...and yes it is rhetoric. 
 
Let's not forget, Paul chose to respond to my tweeting of a link to Matt Barber's column. I prefer blogging because emotion-based bumper sticker slogans may sound nice, but the truth usually requires more substance.

Calling what I write "rhetoric" is not disagreeing with what I wrote or showing where I was in error.

@PlayfulWalrus Your phrase of "neutering marriage" spotlights your bias.
"Neutering marriage" is a more accurate description for what Paul wants than "marriage equality". Brideless or groomless pairings are inherently unequal to marriage, regardless of what state law calls them. Also, unless Paul wants all restrictions on licensing adult relationships lifted, Paul does not support equality the what he claims to. By removing the bride+groom requirement from state licensing, the licenses are being neutered.
When all the gays in the world marry my marriage will be awesome!
I am sorry your marriage and your children's marriages are not capable of handling civil marriage between gays. Mine can!!

I never said my marriage couldn't handle things. What I said was that counterfeiting is harmful. My guess is that Paul would not be happy if Fred Phelps set up a school club and called it a Gay-Straight Alliance. Paul wants to dilute the meaning of the word "marriage". What he wants devalues marriage in general. State licensing is a public matter. This is a public policy matter. We all have to live in the same society, government by the same laws.

@PlayfulWalrus I have a feeling you won't dedicate an hour to an opposing view but an open minded person would: youtube.com/watch?v=4OiDrb…
  I was already aware of that video. People can do all sorts of verbal gymanistics and selective reading to "explain away" every verse of an English language Bible that says anything negative about homosexual behavior. However, that doesn't change the fact that the plain, repetitive teaching of the Bible, literally from the first book to the last, is that marriage unites a bride and a groom, and that sex is for marriage, regardless of where and when someone is living, regardless of whether they are Jew of Gentile.

Regardless of the Bible, however, resisting the neutering of marriage is about scientific, biological, and sociological facts.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

See Things Our Way, Or Else

The conversation I detailed yesterday has continued.

Marriage neutering advocates say that marriage has always been changing, and make claims about past laws regarding marriage that they, and often others, are glad aren’t in place anymore. This, however, does not demonstrate that further change is needed. Also, throughout all of the changes in marriage laws in the past, marriage has always been about uniting the sexes, almost always about uniting one man with one woman. Even in polygynous marriages (Islam, plural marriage of smaller Mormon denominations) and polyandrous marriages (practiced in some places in the East), the people of the same sex are not married to each other, they are each married individually to one person of the opposite sex. The women of "Sister Wives" are not married to each other; each one is seperately married to Kody Brown.

Even in societies where homosexual behavior was publicly accepted, even expected and celebrated, marriage involved uniting the two sexes. That marriage neutering advocates can cite isolated incidents where rogues united a few same-sex couples in a ceremony no more indicates that a same-sex coupling has historically been recognized as marriage than the incidents of women "marrying" themselves demonstrates that marriage only requires one person, or someone "marrying" the Eiffel Tower means that human-building unions have been recognized as "marriage".
Pauls_View  @pauls_view 
@PlayfulWalrus Here is the history of marriage: historyofmarriage.org It has changed many times. You want no more progress. Closes minded.
Paul assumes neutering state marriage licensing is progress, but I don’t agree. He calls me closed minded, but his mind appears to be closed to the idea that uniting the sexes has a distinct value.
In response to what I posted yesterday:

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Opposing Fascism Draws Attacks on the Bible

I tweeted a link to a column by Matt Barber detailing how fascists were going after people for not supporting the neutering of marriage, and I got a response about how the column author was hateful, not about how the column was in error. So I wrote back:

@pauls_view Affirming the Biblical teachings that marriage is bride+groom & sex is for marriage, & resisting fascism is not hateful.

This brought three tweets back from Pauls_View @pauls_view:
@PlayfulWalrus The bible says this about marriage. Can't pick and choose. See picture and versus pic.twitter.com/SkZ4XBwQon
I could write out a long explanation myself, but Alan Shlemon did a great job with these videos responding to stuff like this:

Funding Government: Of Fees and Taxes

How do governments get revenue with which to operate? No, contrary to what some would have you believe, it doesn’t magically appear out of nothing. There are some basic ways governments are funded:

Conquest, thereby gaining resources previously outside of that government's domain

Owning businesses, thereby selling goods and services.

Collecting rent

Selling land or mining rights, etc.

Gifts

Customs duties and tariffs on imported or exported goods

Taxes

Fees

Assessments

Fines and forfeitures


Some sources would list loans, bonds, tributes, and subventions, but each of these eventually necessitate one of the other funding means previously listed.

Let’s take a closer look at these funding methods.

Despite what the America-bashers say, we haven’t engaged in conquest in a long time. Very few people would advocate conquest in the historic sense. I do think a valid argument could be made for seizing the assets of nongovernmental terrorist groups and using those to fund our anti-terrorism efforts and to compensate American victims of terrorism.

The government should own very few, if any businesses. Free markets can take care of the needs there.

Collecting rent, for any land the government owns, is certainly valid. That rent should go first and foremost to the maintenance of that property.

Selling land and mineral rights. This could be a good idea. The government needs a certain amount of land for essential Constitutional functions, but otherwise should consider getting out of being a landowner.

People sometimes give gifts to local government, such as donating their land to be a municipal park upon their death. Gifts, such as statues, may come from other places. Gifts to governments should be under certain narrow circumstances to avoid the appearance of undue influence.

The "buy American" crowd loves the idea of duties and tariffs on imports.  However, these keep prices high for American consumers and reduce the incentive to Americans to provide goods and services that will be desired around the world.

Now we’re getting to the nitty-gritty.

Taxes are forced and supposedly for a common benefit. We have income taxes, capital gains taxes, property taxes, estate taxes, sales taxes, luxury taxes, sin taxes, gas taxes, so on and so forth. Although I highly doubt it will ever happen, most of these should be done away with. A sales tax may work, provided the government doesn’t lose too much through underground markets. Sales taxes will still mean "the rich" will be likely to pay most of the tax burden, because they tend to buy more expensive items. We should not allow taxes to be called “fees” for the sake of political comfort.

Fees are for a special benefit, collected upon a transaction. For example, not everyone owns a motorized vehicle. Some people own many. If we’re going to have government regulation of motorized vehicles and government programs and projects centering on them, it makes sense to charge fees for registering those vehicles in a way that covers enough of the costs so that someone who does not own such a vehicle does not have to pay a tax to support them. Retailers pay fees in order to have their scales and registers certified as accurate. Fees should not be used like income taxes. They should fund a specific, related purpose.

Assessments are charged on a property, usually for an extraordinary expense, such as public works or utility infrastructure construction. Assessments make more sense than most taxes, though in some cases, the same results can be achieved through private property and private infrastructure. For example, property owners in a certain area may pay an assessment to build and maintain a nearby bridge.

Provided they do not violate property rights, fines and forfeitures are another excellent way to fund government functions, and they do so widely now. When someone violates laws, necessitating a response from government, it would be ideal if they could pay for the costs of enforcement, investigation, conviction, and maybe even incarceration. If someone can make money by violating the law and a fine will only amount to a small percentage of their illicit gain, that is hardly a deterrent. But it makes sense to "tax" crime with fines and forfeitures.

So, taxes are not fees, fees are not taxes, and we should not try to hide taxes as fees nor treat fees like taxes. There are many ways for the government to fund its necessary functions without raising or even having income taxes or estate taxes.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Hank Hanegraaff on Neutering Marriage and Hit & Run Bible Mockers

Hank Hanegraaff, culture warrior, is a longtime husband and father of 12 children. If understand correctly, nine of those children are biological (one of which miscarried) and three are adopted. So, he has a lot of perspective on marriage, family, and parenting. He has a new blog that appears to be intentionally distinct from the ministry he leads. Two recent entries are relevant to the issue of neutering marriage.

The first is "What Are the Inherent Liabilities of [Neutering] Marriage?"
Furthermore, we should underscore the biological reality of sexual reproduction. Every organ in the human body is self-sufficient to perform its intended function except for one. Natural reproduction always, always, always requires a coupling of male and female. As Dr. Jay Richards has well written in the Christian Research Journal, “Marriage protects, reflects, and reinforces this powerful complementary, reproductive part of our natures.” As such, marriage “is a comprehensive union of body, mind, emotion, and soul, a proper end of which is children.”
One need not even cite reproduction. It is a biological fact that men and women are different. All one must do is note that men and women are different and thus the uniting of both sexes is different from other kinds of associations. States are allowed to treat different kinds of associations differently. This is not a religious argument, it is an argument based on basic biological reality that most people understand and live by, with perhaps the exception of a very, very few people, most of whom required many years of brainwashing to arrive at their stated opinion. and unless they are neuterally bisexual, they are hypocrites.
In sum, marriage cannot be reduced to politically correct rhetoric or political whims. It is a matter of natural law. Says Richards, “Rights come from our nature, and our nature comes from God. If you deny that, then you deny the basis of all our other rights.” In the end, redefining marriage strikes a mortal blow to the foundation of a free society.
This is no small matter. because of the flouting of so much other "traditional morality" in having sex and raising children out of wedlock, shacking up, adultery, what I would call elective divorces, and elective abortions, too many people think it won't feel any different if marriage is neutered, and so there is no harm in it. However, the arguments driving the neutering of marriage undermine the very foundation of our rights, making them nothing more than things doled out by whomever is currently in office. In gaining the "right" to get a state license without a bride or without a groom (which is not just limited to homosexual people - anyone can access this "right" just as homosexual individuals can access bride+groom licenses), all rights are being weakend.

Hanegraaff's entry offers:
See also Jay W. Richards, “To Defend Marriage, We Should Learn a Lesson from Apologetics,” Christian Research Journal, vol. 35, no. 4, 2012.

Bible Answer Man interview with Jay W. Richards, “What is marriage?”
http://www.equip.org/audio/hank-hanegraaff-with-special-guest-jay-w-richards/
The second entry is "Can Christians Only 'Thump the Bible' On the Issue of [Neutering] Marriage Legislation?"
When the Bible is being denigrated, mocked, disdained, as sarcasm drip from the lips of political pundits and public personalities, we must take a stand, because the lives of multiplied millions literally hang in the balance.
He takes Bill O’Reilly and Lawrence O'Donnell to task.
In reality, MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell is himself a “thumper;” a “thumper” who has taken the Bible out of context and used it as a pretext for his own idiosyncratic brand of fundamentalism. To anachronistically rip a narrative out of its Ancient Near Eastern context and then use it as a demonstration of the superiority of modern pluralist assumptions, I think is at best misguided. And to read anachronistic modern meanings into an Ancient Near Eastern context is hardly enlightened. Instead of reading anachronistic prejudices into the text of the Bible, O’Donnell would have been well-served to read the Bible synergistically. One can no more read New World realities into Ancient Near Eastern legalities than read Torah legalities into New Covenant realities. He cannot comprehend the Bible as a whole without comprehending its individual passages. And He cannot comprehend its individual passages apart from, well, comprehending the Bible as a whole.

Lawrence O’Donnell’s bigotry has done a grave injustice to the majesty of the most significant book in the history of Western civilization. If indeed, O’Donnell had an adequate understanding of the rich tradition of biblical Judaism, he would not have been so cavalier in his diatribe against Old Testament Jewish jurisprudence. Because complex codes regarding the propriety of human relationships are hardly reducible to superficial sound bites like those emanating from his mouth.
That's just a taste of the two entries.

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Does the Constitution Prohibit Voting According Religious Beliefs?

The answer should be obvious, but all throughout the push to neuter marriage, people have said things that either explicitly or implicity indicate that those with religious beliefs about sex and marriage that are incompatible with those of the Left are not allowed to vote according to thier beliefs. The same goes for abortion.

To give you an example, on March 9, 2009 the Orange County Register printed a short letter from a Carey Strombotne that asked "If church and state are separate, why then do religious people have the right to weigh in on the issue of Proposition 8?"

The  paper subsequently printed several responses at this URL. (Note that the OCR now has a paywall in place.)

It is a perversion of the American system to suggest that citizens should not be able to vote according to their conscience. If that includes notions that are also found in tradtional, organized religion, so be it. Non-religious arguments have been made for the California Marriage Amendment and similar laws. Non-religious arguments have been made supporting the state's interest in licensing marriage as something uniting the sexes.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Is Your News Source Lying To You?

Whether is it supposed to be an objective news article or report, or whether is commentary or analysis, if the person you are reading, listening to, or watching is discussing the public debate and court arguments about neutering marriage, the federal Defense of Marriage Act, or California's Proposition 8 says any of the following, they are are most likely lying to you, whether out of appallingly unprofessional ignorance or dishonest advocacy:

"ban on gay marriage"
"ban on gay unions"
"illegal" in reference to homosexual relationships
"equal rights" or "civil rights" in regards to homosexual people
"The only arguments against gay/same-sex marriage are religious."
"The only arguments defending Proposition 8 or DOMA are religious."
"Their argument is that marriage is only about having children/reproduction/procreation."

Again, if you hear/read any of those, or their equivalents, the person is lying to you.

Here's the truth:

The California Marriage Amendment, voted in as Proposition 8, and similar legislation in other states, did not ban any marriages, unions, ceremonies, or relationships. It did not make any of those things illegal.

As it was before Proposition 8 or any of those other laws passed, a homosexual person has equal - the exact same - rights and access as a heterosexual person.

There are nonreligious arguments defending the Constitutionality, practicality, and importance of the bride+groom requirement in state marriage licensing.

The argument is not that marriage is only about having children. Read this very slowly if you have to: The argument is that since man+woman pairing is the only kind of pairing that can naturally (and "accidentally") create new citizens who do not consent to the situation in which they are placed, that kind of voluntary association is distinguishable from man+man pairing or woman+woman pairing and the state has more interest in man+woman pairings.

Whether someone wants to have children or not, plans to have children or not, has all of their reproductive system functioning or not are all private matters. However, because of science (don't be anti-science!) and thousands of years of experience the state knows a man+man or woman+woman union will never naturally or accidentally produce children, so they can be ruled out of this level of interest. One may ask, as Justice Kagan did, about a couple of 55-year-olds, but 1) the law doesn't know when any given couple will become jointly infertile, and 2) they are still the same kind of pairing that is reproductive. Checking a birth certificate or other official government documents to see if the sex-integration requirement (bride+groom) is met is simple and non-intrusive. Asking about plans/desires to have children or personal infertility is unnecessary and a violation of privacy.

We have repeatedly demonstrated the bias of certain news media personnel and organizations in these matters. I give my feedback to them. You should, too.

Previously:

Neutered Marriage Means Marriage Can't Be About Children

Neutering Marriage: Where We Are and What It Means

Manipulation & Misreporting of Polls to Advocate Marriage Neutering

Marriage Neutering and Newspeak

It's Not a "Ban on Gay Marriage"

Two comprehensive offerings:
Reviewing the Basics
Handy Dandy Marriage Neutering Plea Repellant

Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Bad Arguments For Neutering Marriage Licensing

I’m against changing marriage licensing so that legal marriage will no longer mean uniting the sexes. Some people claim to be in favor of “gay marriage”, but this is a misnomer. I'm in favor of gay marriage - my own marriage is quite gay, thank you. Changing the legal definition of marriage means forcing everyone to apply the title "marriage" to, and treat as marriage, sex-segregated or sex-exclusive or same-sex or single-sex or brideless and groomless unions. There would be no requirements that the participants actually be gay.

Originally inspired by a blog posting by Greg Koukl, I wanted to bring you some bad arguments for changing marriage licensing to license couples missing one of the sexes. Koukl has a more in-depth piece here

Keep in mind – marriage licenses are issued by the state, on behalf of the citizens of that state.


Here's a survey of some arguments we have heard from marriage neutering advocates as to why the Supreme Court of the United States should neuter state marriage licensing nationwide.

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Schools Aren't Required to Teach Marriage

That was the response given by the "No on Prop 8" side in their ads, trying to counter the "Yes on Prop 8" ads saying that same-sex "marriage" will be taught in public schools. (Proposition 8, of course, WAS passed and thus amended the California constitution.)

If you wanted a case study in bad argumentation, "schools aren’t required to teach about marriage" would be a good one.

I originally had considered this more in light of polls that predicted Prop 8 would be defeated, and wondering how we can hold the marriage neutering and homosexuality advocates to their word should Prop 8 fail.  After all, they said over and over again that they won't interfere with churches and freedom of religion (but well after Prop 8 was voted up, they did attack churches, including the Crystal Cathedral) and that they won't push marriage neutering ideology in the schools.

Oops – no they didn’t.  They’ve said "schools aren’t required to teach marriage".  That’s a far different thing than "schools won’t be teaching same-sex marriage".

Now, none of their ads could be used in a court cases as binding promises, so they could misdirect, use weasel words, and lie up and down, because when it comes down to it, none of it would matter – in court – after the election, nor would it matter after SCOTUS rules. With Prop 8, the California Marriage Amendment in place, and other laws like it on other states, it will be easier for parents to shield their children from marriage neutering propaganda. Without it, it will be much more difficult, if not impossible.  However – we can still socially shame the marriage neutering side by exposing them as liars, and that might help in some future battles. Although, they seem to have no shame.

The most honest response the "No" side (the marriage neutering side) could have given to the "Yes" side's playing of the "school" card is: "Of course same-sex marriage will be taught in schools – why shouldn’t it be? We think that is a good thing."

But the "No" side knew that too many voters would be persuaded to the "Yes" side if they made that admission. So they were misleading people, knowing that all they needed was the "No" vote (or an activist court) and they wouldn't have to bother with as many costly court fights, and wouldn't be held to their word in a legal sense. The fact that they are liars and deceivers will have no legal consequences for them.

Let's consider how ridiculous it is to say "Schools aren’t required to teach marriage."

Let’s assume that the statement is factually true to the letter of the law. There’s no requirement that I put gasoline or any fuel into my automobile. There is no requirement that I earn income. There is probably no requirement that our schools teach that George Washington was the first President under this Constitution. But if I want to drive my automobile anywhere, I need fuel.  If I want to pay my bills, I need to earn income. If we're going to teach history, it would absurd not to teach about George Washington.

The sentence could also be considered incomplete. "Schools aren’t required to teach marriage…unless they teach sex education."  Ninety-six percent of the schools in California did in 2008.

How could schools not teach marriage?  Marriage is the basic building block of society.  There are going to be mentions of marriage in civics, political science, history, economics, home economics, health, social studies, sociology, psychology, biology, literature, comparative religion, art – and who knows what else.  Should the example of marriage not be used in any word problems in mathematics, in learning languages, in grammar instruction? Are the personal lives of teachers and school staff never going to be discussed – as in a teacher mentioning his wife?

Well, maybe the mention of marriage will be removed as much as possible. Notice that the "No" side didn’t use the words "gay" or "homosexual" or "same-sex" in their statement that "Schools aren’t required to teach marriage." So they weren’t saying that "Schools aren’t required to teach same-sex marriage." Because if marriage is discussed in a public (state) school, of course the marriage neutering activists are going to make sure that it is discussed according to official state policy – which, with the state marriage licensing neutered, is that there is no difference between natural marriage and neutered marriage.

The only way to get around that is to not discuss marriage at all.  They could offer to do just that – essentially ban the word "marriage" from the classroom. For some of the Left, that might be exactly what they want anyway. After all, doesn’t promoting or esteeming marriage hurt the feelings of those who choose not to marry, or have been unable to find a willing spouse?  And so, "Schools aren’t required to teach marriage" seems to me to possibly be a veiled offer to "compromise", like when someone is counterfeiting your branded merchandise and they offer to "compromise" with you.

We do want marriage taught in our schools – natural, historic, bride+groom marriage. Why?  Because strong marriage correlates to a strong society. The more children raised within marriage, the better off society is.

Finally, I’ll focus on the word "required".  Since when have the homosexuality advocates – or just about anyone on the Left - ever waited for permission, let alone a requirement? They go ahead and do everything they can to indoctrinate anyone else – including children – unless they are somehow barred from doing so. They think it is better to beg (often insincerely) forgiveness than ask permission. Actually, they think it is better to accuse you of being a bigot than beg forgiveness.

That is one reason why we argued in favor of Prop 8. It The California Marriage Amendment, like laws in other states, gives parents more of a possibility of barring the indoctrinators from lecturing their child, at least when it comes to marriage.

Since I first wrote these thoughts on the day that Proposition 8 was voted up and the California constitution amended, the Leftist California lawmakers adopted a requirement that school textbooks highlight the "contributions" of "LGBT" persons. Apparently, if someone invented something, it makes a difference whether he was attracted to women or men. I'm certain that one of those "contributions" will be the drive to neuter marriage. So, Judge Walker, who it appears to me and many others, acted unethically to attack the California constitution, would be featured positively for his work in neutering marriage. This legislation alone proves how dishonest the marriage neutering advocates were and still are.

Saturday, March 23, 2013

It Takes a Bride and Groom to Make a Marriage

Throughout history, from culture to culture, around the world, marriage has always been about uniting the two sexes. The state did not create marriage; marriage helped create the state and the state simply has recognized and licensed marriage. The idea that there could be a marriage without a bride or without a groom is a very recent concept that tries to do away with marriage, first by replacing it with a counterfeit. It has been around a little over a decade as a legal concept, first appearing in the Netherlands. None of the great human or civil rights leaders in history ever spoke about a "right" to "marry" someone of the same sex. It's a made-up right, unlike the rights written of in the the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence and elsewhere by the men who wrote and adopted those documents, which were seen as bestowed upon us by our Creator.

So marriage uniting a bride and groom is the default position. The marriage neutering advocates get all excited when someone announces their support for neutering marriage, but what we're not hearing are the 6,000,000,000 or so people in the world who understand marriage unites a bride and groom. Almost all of them DON'T send out a press release, tweet, or hold a press conference announcing their support for preserving the bride+groom requirement in marriage law. The marriage neutering advocates trumpet the news when those in power of a US state or a country abandon sense and capitulates to the whiny, petulant, narcissistic activists. But that still leaves the heavy majority of US states strongly in favor of keeping marriage laws reserved for marriage, and over 180 countries where people understand that there's no such thing as "same-sex marriage".

With that in mind, let's look at some of the statements made by marriage neutering advocates. 

A Few Helpful Illustrations About Marriage

It is Constitutional to treat different actions and different kinds of associations differently. State marriage licenses that require the participation of both a bride (woman) and a groom (man) are inclusive and are equally accessible to individuals regardless of their sex or sexual orientation, and thus are not unconstitutional. Remember that adult relationships with unrelated people are voluntary, and that someone not wanting a license under the required conditions is still offered access to them.

The uniting of a man and woman is the only kind or type of relationship that will naturally create the next generation of citizens, even if not all do. Those new citizens are subjected to this reltionship whether they like it or not. The state has more interest in protecting children than consenting adults. The state simply does not have the same interest in a relationship that 1) does not include both sexes that comprise all of society and 2) will never naturally or as efficiently create the next generation of citizens.

Here's another illustration that might help:


Marriage neutering advocates don't want there to be a word that describes the bride+groom relationship. Requiring both a man and a woman participate is marriage equality. Here's a simple way to explain the concept to someone:


Finally, while one need not disapprove of homosexual behavior or demonstrate that parenting by a homosexual couple harms children in order to effectively defend the bride+groom requirement in marriage licensing, I found this interesting:



The Regnerus study supports gender-inclusive parenting.

Friday, March 22, 2013

Why Marriage Matters

What is the purpose of licensing marriage?

Some Gays and Lesbians Oppose Neutering of Marriage

...especially by judicial fiat.

I can only imagine the vitriol that must be spewed towards Doug Mainwaring, a self-identified gay man and co-founder of the National Capital Tea Party Patriots. Despite what some Leftists say, there is not even the slightest conflict between being a TEA or Tea Party member and being a homosexual person, as the Tea Party movement is focused on fiscal policy. He probably still gets attacks from ignorant people for that, but I'm sure he's getting attacked for his opinion pieces, like one that was printed in the Washington Post, "Why I Oppose Gay Marriage".