Friday, March 22, 2013

Manipulation & Misreporting of Polls to Advocate Marriage Neutering

All the cool people want it! All the young people want it! The majority of Americans want it! The momentum is unstoppable! It's inevitable!

How many times have you heard that in the debate about the neutering (abolishing) of state marriage licenses? Eager to advance the replacement of marriage with a a counterfeit, in-the-tank reporters and Leftist advocacy groups have touted polling that, according to them, shows a strong majority of Americans on their side of the issue.

However, if it was really true, they'd simply neuter marriage nationwide through direct popular votes on the state level, at least in states that have direct voting, and through state legislature in the other states and Congress nationally. For all of their bluster, there has only ever been ONE state (Maine) that has initiated the neutering of their licenses through a direct vote of the people, and that was done in the November 2012 election. For the other eight states and Washington, D.C., the process was initiated by judicial activism or radical action by the state legislature. This whole thing was initiated through judicial activism. Unfortunately, some people do throw up their hands and bow down before such activism, or before the radical agenda of their state legislature. 41 of the 50 states do NOT have neutered licensing, and most of them have recently, strongly, affirmed marriage as a bride+groom union, many by popular vote.

In the last few weeks, there have been reports of various polls claiming that clear a majority of Americans support the neutering marriage and polls touted by marriage neutering advocates claiming that 49% of Americans support marriage neutering. I wasn't a math major at the university, but 49% is not a majority (unless marriage neutering advocates have been allowed to redefine the word "majority" like they have "marriage" in some places).

The truth?

You're being lied to by marriage neutering advocates. Headlines about these polls are almost always highly misleading and the articles themselves may be misleading. When it comes to polling, the wording of the questions, the order of the questions, and who was polled, among other factors, can make a difference. At The Opine Editorials, we documented this repeatedly in our updates about poll dancing.

Even homofascist marriage neutering advocate blog Dog My Joe, by its own postings, admits this. A recent update there quoted Tony Perkins criticizing the Washington Post:

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Which is Not Needed? Mothers or Fathers?

Those "tolerant" and "it's all about love" marriage neutering advocates are attacking this 11 year-old girl for her excellent comments before a legislative committee in Minnesota. Notice there is nothing hateful about her comments, nothing disapproving of homosexual people or homosexual behavior. Some of these vulgar and libelous attackers accuse her parents of using her to promote their own agenda. I wonder if these same critics made the same comments about children who have made comments before legislators about being raised by gay or lesbians couples?

SSM Advocate Admits Prop 8 Voters Not Haters

And he admited the voters were actually more in favor of Prop 8 than the vote indicated. David Fleischer had a commentary in the Los Angeles Times analyzing the vote for California’s Proposition 8, with the hope of eventually repealing the California Marriage Amendment. He mades some surprising admissions. Fleischer headed the LGBT mentoring project, which is now part of the Los Angeles Gay and Lesbian Center's new leadership program Learn Act Build.
Immediately after Proposition 8 passed, many who supported [neutering] marriage tried to make sense of the results.
Here's the sense: Most people, even if they retain no disapproval of homosexual behavior, understand that marriage unites the sexes, and that the state has an interest in marriage that it doesn't have with other kinds of voluntary personal relationships. Also, they don't like the judiciary usurping their authority.
A set of assumptions gained wide acceptance. Some are correct. Most, however, are just plain wrong. And it's crucial that we know what happened in the last election before launching another attempt to legalize marriage for all.
For all? Really? Even for a bisexual who is in love with two people at the same time?

Lesbians Report That Lesbians Make Good Mothers

Alice Park reported on a study that claims children do better with lesbian mothers than heterosexual parents, whether or not the mother has a partner. Now, before any men try to get out of their fatherhood obligations by bringing this to the attention of family court judges, let's take a closer look at what is really being claimed here. After all, it can't just be a celibate straight woman raising the child by herself. No, according to this, it is important that the woman be attracted to other women. That a child's mother is attracted to other women makes the kid do better in math. Right. Now golf, I could believe.
That is the question researchers explored in the first study ever to track children raised by lesbian parents, from birth to adolescence.
I'm not sure what the wording of this means. Does this mean the kids were raised from birth to adolescence by lesbians, or that they were only tracked through adolescence? From the rest of the article, it appears to mean both. I suppose I should know from the comma.
Although previous studies have indicated that children with same-sex parents show no significant differences compared with children in heterosexual homes when it comes to social development and adjustment, many of those investigations involved children who were born to women in heterosexual marriages, who later divorced and came out as lesbians.
One important detail is what exactly is meant by social development and adjustment, and how that is determined.
For their new study, published on Monday in the journal Pediatrics, researchers Nanette Gartrell, a professor of psychiatry at the University of California at San Francisco (and a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles), and Henry Bos, a behavioral scientist at the University of Amsterdam, focused on what they call planned lesbian families - households in which the mothers identified themselves as lesbian at the time of artificial insemination.
So it appears none of these children were "surprises" or conceived via rape, or otherwise "crisis pregnancies". This is very important. Perhaps the real message is that waiting to have children until you believe you are ready to be a parent makes things better for the child? A child born to a partnered lesbian impregnated through third party reproduction is going to have two women who consider that child their child, unlike how it often can be when a man has been cuckolded and is bitter or comes into a situation where a woman is raising a child from a past lover.

The authors found that children raised by lesbian mothers - whether the mother was partnered or single - scored very similarly to children raised by heterosexual parents on measures of development and social behavior.
There are so many factors consider for both the homosexual and heterosexual parents – divorce, strife in the relationships, individual flaws, etc.
These findings were expected, the authors said; however, they were surprised to discover that children in lesbian homes scored higher than kids in straight families on some psychological measures of self-esteem and confidence, did better academically and were less likely to have behavioral problems, such as rule-breaking and aggression.
Self-esteem and confidence aren't necessarily good things – especially when they are unwarranted. Rule-breaking can be a good thing when the rule is unjust. Aggression is not necessarily a bad thing. For example, if a bully is about to beat up a smaller child, perhaps citing that smaller child’s mother being a lesbian, then aggressive intervention on the part of a witness can be a good thing even if the school has a rule against intervening.
In addition, children in same-sex-parent families whose mothers ended up separating did as well as children in lesbian families in which the moms stayed together.
Does anyone really believe this? It means that same-sex divorce has no effect on children. Really, rather than getting this study widely publicized, if I had come up with these results, I would realize that the study is flawed. But due to politics, and the funding already spent by homosexuality advocates on the study, the study gets wide publicity.
The data that Gartrell and Bos analyzed came from the U.S. National Longitudinal Lesbian Family Study (NLLFS), begun in 1986. The authors included 154 women in 84 families who underwent artificial insemination to start a family; the parents agreed to answer questions about their children's social skills, academic performance and behavior at five follow-up times over the 17-year study period. Children in the families were interviewed by researchers at age 10 and were then asked at age 17 to complete an online questionnaire, which included queries about the teens' activities, social lives, feelings of anxiety or depression, and behavior.
Where to start?
1. That's an extremely small sample.
2. What about when these kids get older, especially when they consider starting their own family?
3. Are the misandry levels in these children higher than the general population?
4. Is it possible that the researchers doing the interviews were biased?
5. Is it possible that the self-reporting could have been defensive?
Not surprisingly, the researchers found that 41% of children reported having endured some teasing, ostracism or discrimination related to their being raised by same-sex parents.
Unfortunately, some children bully other children for anything they perceive as different. Bullying for whatever reasons is not good, even more so when it is something over which the child has no control.
But Gartrell and Bos could find no differences on psychological adjustment tests between the children and those in a group of matched controls.
This could mean that everyone is getting bullied at pretty much the same rate, regardless of the sexual identity of parents.

I do think is entirely possible that a child raised by two stable women (or one woman) would be better off than one raised by a woman who has a series of bad boys parading through her bedroom and past the breakfast table, possibly taking a detour through the child's room between. But what about situations where a mother and grandmother are raising the children, or a mother and aunt?

Apples need to be compared to apples. Of course a child is likely to be better off raised by a generally good, financially stable woman who planned the pregnancy over an abusive mother and abusive father who are in and out of police custody and spend their money on their substance abuse habits rather than food for the kid, and got pregnant as a natural result of sex without actually intending to become parents. But what about all other things being equal?

The study does not past the smell test. Homosexual people KNOW there is a difference between men and women in interpersonal relationships - that is why they indentify as homosexual and not neutrally bisexual. Parenting is an interpersonal relationship. Therefore, there has to be a difference between mothering and fathering. All children, gay or straight, will grow up to deal with both men and women. As such, they benefit from having a parent of each sex parenting them and modeling cooperative interaction between the sexes.

Use common sense. Does the fact that a woman is attracted to a woman matter? What matters is the behavior towards and in front of the children. Of course a lesbian can be a good mother. What she can't be, though, nor can another woman, is a father.
Because the research is ongoing, Gartrell hopes to test some of these theories with additional studies. She is also hoping to collect more data on gay-father households; gay fatherhood is less common than lesbian motherhood because of the high costs of surrogacy or adoption that gay couples face in order to start a family.
But I thought they were just like bride+groom couples? If they are, some of those couples should be able to make babies without third parties.

Would the same publication publish a study that was funded and released by Focus on the Family in which evangelical Christian parents raised children according to the principles of Focus on the Family, and the study said that such children are better off?

Why Just Two?

Many marriage neutering advocates tell us, even though they insist that marriage isn't about children, that all that matters is that a child has two parents in the home.


Where do they get this number?

Neutered Marriage Means Marriage Can’t Be About Children

Some marriage neutering advocates openly or quietly support changing marriage laws (and other laws) to accommodate polygamy and consensual incest. Then there are marriage neutering advocates who scoff when marriage defenders, clumsily or skillfully, ask why public policy regarding marriage should be changed so radically to remove the all-through-history-universal bride+groom core, but not changed to accomodate polygamous and incestuous marriages, which have been historically recognized as valid marriages. Marriage neutering advocates who claim their arguments should not be applied to give polygamists or incestuous couples their "right to marry" often claim polygamy and incest are harmful to children.

This is a curious objection, because that argument rests on the claim that marriage is tied to heterosexual intercourse, childbearing, and childrearing. Yet, what about same-sex incest and polygamy (which also eliminates the "harmful to women" objection)? And haven't the marriage neutering advocates been arguing that marriage should not be associated with heterosexual intercourse, nor the ability or desire to bear children?

No two men together can ever naturally produce a child. So if two men with no ability to produce children nor any desire to raise children can form a marriage, marriage, as an institution, can't be about children - children are merely incidental to marriage, just like whether the couple rents or owns their residence.

Nor can we say that marriage must mean that we can expect any given sex act to be part of marriage.

Doesn't this mean we can't grant marriage licenses to brideless or groomless couples while legitimately denying those licenses to polygamous or incestuous unions on the grounds of harm to children or the illegality of incestuous sex, because there is no connection between marriage and sex or children?

So, marriage neutering advocates: either tell us what non-arbitrary, consistent argument is there that demands same-sex pairings must be issued state marriage licenses that does not also apply to polygamous or incestuous relationships, or stop scoffing when this is invoked in the defense of existing marriage laws.

Can I please have my own Google Bomb Website now? Please? Have someone who preaches against bullying go ahead and hypocritically bully me that way like they did that other guy.

While we're at it, since marriage is not about children in their perspective, can any marriage neutering advocate explain why a man who has impregnated a woman should have any obligation to propose marriage or actually get married/speed up the wedding date? Also, please explain why any married couple with minor children together should take that into consideration when deciding whether or not to divorce. I'm not talking about law here, but rather peer pressure, morality, etc. (The sad thing is, too many people already don't believe pregnancy should have any effect on whether/when there is a marriage, or whether/when to divorce.)

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Marriage Neutering and Newspeak

Marriage neutering advocates, especially those embedded in the MSM, have been very clever at their manipulation of the news and debate when it comes to their well-organized, well-funded, calculated effort to neuter marriage licensing nationwide and replace marriage with a counterfeit, further tearing down the strength of the family and devaluing both masculinity and femininity. Hedonists want this because they don't like anything that implies sexual morality. For the Leftists, this is a good thing because they think it will bring about more equality in outcomes and make people generally more dependent on the government. To Leftists, that some people have better families than others is unfairness that must be corrected by public policy. People relying on family first, ahead of government, might mean having to deal with people who know your moral shortcomings and your counterproductive habits, and that can be a real buzzkill.

They know they can't win using logic and sound reasoning, so they appeal to emotion and employ cultural subversion. They know the fact that men and women are different is inescapable, despite the long attempts by Leftist gender confusion advocates to assert otherwise. Even infants know men and women are different. Even the marriage neutering advocates at "Dancing With the Stars" always pair men with women, even going so far as to pair Chaz Bono with a woman because Chaz claims to be man now (though the emperor has no Y chromosome). Any person who has struggled with their sexual orientation and has identified themselves as "gay" or "lesbian" is demonstrating that there are important differences between men and women. Anyone who claims to have undergone a gender reassignment is making a claim that there is such a difference between men and women, that counseling, hormone treatments and surgeries are needed for them to change from one to the other.

Since men and women are different, the uniting of a bride and groom is objectively, demonstrably, and documentably different than the pairing two men or two women. This is why it is Constitutional (and important) to treat marriage differently from other kinds of voluntary associations, including what a minority of states and a few countries have falsely called "marriage" in their licensing.

In an effort to circumvent what should be self-evident truths to most people, marriage neutering advocates have misused language.

Let's clear up some terms.

Prejudice:

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Not All Freedoms are Rights

We often hear politicians and activists talking about "rights", as in a right to health insurance, or "We should not take away a couple's right to marry" or there should be a "right" to just about anything.  I have said before that true rights do not obligate others without their consent. God (that's Nature, to you pagans, philosophical naturalists, etc.) has given us many rights. The government does not give us rights. It is supposed to protect our rights from those who would infringe upon them by force or fraud. The Constitution does not give us our rights. It lists some of our rights, but it also says that we retain all rights and powers not specifically given over to the government in the Constitution.

There can be a difference between a right and a freedom.  Not everything that we have the freedom to do is a right. For example, we can run through an open field because it is open. We can have that freedom.  But if that field is owned by someone else, we do not have a right to run through it. If that owner decides to fence off the property, our freedom to run across it is gone, but we have not lost any right. I have the freedom to order a pizza from Domino's. But if they decide not to sell pizzas anymore, I can't say that they've taken away my right. What would be a violation of my rights would be if the federal government told me I could not freely exchange something I had for a pizza being offered freely for trade by Domino's.

So the next time you see someone claiming that their "right" will be taken away, think about whether what they are talking about is really a right or if it has been a freedom they've enjoyed.

Earth is Round, Children Need a Mother and Father

Here's something I posted early on in my contributions to The Opine Editorials...

Dr. Amy Tuteur, a Harvard and Boston University-educated obstetrician-gynecologist, wrote a piece on Salon.com entitled "Are Fathers Optional?" Since she answers in the negative, affirming the importance of fathers, there have been some very passionate responses that you can click through to see. It seems like it should be self-evident that both mother and fathers are necessary for children, and thus, raising the next generation in the best social conditions possible. Sadly, because this is not affirming of some of the desires and choices of some adults (especially some unilateralists, feminists, male hedonists, and some homosexual people) it is treated as a controversial idea.

Judging by their behavior, American women appear to think that fathers are optional. According to the recently published birth statistics (Births: Final Data for 2006), the proportion of births to unmarried women has reached 38.5%, the highest rate ever recorded.
That's an average. Some groups often portrayed as disadvantaged have a much higher rate, unfortunately, which helps perpetuate disadvantages in those populations.
Women are actively conceiving and bearing children in the knowledge that their fathers will almost certainly not be living with them throughout childhood. Simply put, women are behaving as if fathers are optional. Nothing could be further from the truth. Having an active, involved, resident father is the birth right of every child. It is not the birth right of every mother to have children simply because she wants them.
I urge you to click through and read the whole piece. It isn't very long. The M.D. does participate in the comments thread, responding to objections and challenges – most of which are typical. Some examples of some of her replies to the critics:
Actually I believe that women should we stigmatized if they want to have children without marriage, because it is a self indulgent, selfish choice... Hetero is normative. That doesn't mean the gay is unacceptable, but let's not get ridiculous... I can understand why a woman would want a child, but I cannot understand a woman putting what she wants ahead of what a child needs... We can debate the research findings and they are important, but my argument is primarily a moral argument. All children have a mother and father, but in the case of gay couples the biological parent substitutes someone he or she likes better. That may be nice for the biological parent, but it is not fair to the child... I realize that placing children's needs above parents' wants is not politically correct. That's because, in our society, children are treated like accessories, not like actual human beings... Sorry, the fact that some people are horrible parents does not give you the moral right to be a mediocre parent, or, indeed, anything except the best parent that you can be... If the mother and father cannot commit to being permanently resident in that child's life, they shouldn't have a child.
And that's just a small sampling. I wonder if she'd like to join this blog? ;-) H/T: Glenn Sacks

Monday, March 18, 2013

Pseudogamy

Anthony Esolen at Mere Comments has posted a blog entry on "Pseudogamy".
Our problem is pseudogamy, false marriage, and it assumes many forms. Same-sex pseudogamy is but the latest and most flagrantly absurd, but it is not the first. We find the most fundamental form, from which other corruptions rise up like diseases, when a man and woman go through the ceremony and utter the traditional words "as long as you both shall live," while harboring the mental reservation, "as long, that is, as I am happy," or "as long as the marriage 'works,'" whatever that is supposed to mean.
Click through to read the whole thing. It is mostly about divorce and harboring reservations when marrying. I disagree with him where he knocks pre-nups as either the bride, the groom, or both planning for divorce, and thus negating the spiritual aspect of the marriage. As long as divorce, especially no-fault divorce, is a legal reality (and I don't expect it this will change prior to the return of Christ), the laws and courts already amount to a de facto pre-nup. Why should a bride and groom let strangers decide for them when they can decide as a couple while on good terms?

Pseudogamy 102:
Man and woman unite in marriage to bring into being a new generation; and even when they cannot do so, because of age or some physical defect, they may well wish to do so, or they stand for others as exemplars of the act that naturally brings forth children.
From Pseudogamy 103:
To play at marriage before marriage causes one to play at play-marriage after marriage; the sharp distinction is lost ("It's only a piece of paper!" laugh those who fear the marriage certificate), and both the unmarried and the married states are thereby corrupted.
I do not doubt that there is a connection between other forms of psuedogamy (among other things) and the push to neuter marriage. We would not be at this point unless without much previous error. Error begets error, unfortunately. Some of my own past actions have contributed to this mess. However, I admit that those things were wrong to do. I do advise others not to do them. I don't make excuses, or demand approval and affirmation for those or any legal entitlements because I did them. I am not trying to get any media portrayal or school or church to say those actions weren't wrong. I don't pretend that those actions were no different than being married.

From Pseudogamy 104:
Masculinity and femininity are like languages, each with a certain noticeable character, with delimiting features that are ineradicable from that character. As with a language, you never know what a culture will "say" with its men or women, or what any particular man or woman will "say" with the physical and mental makeup, not to mention the cultural expectations based upon those, which he or she is provided with. There is, literally, an infinite number of possible things to say; but there is also an infinite number of things that will not be said or that cannot conceivably be said.
From Pseudogamy 105:
You cannot, in a vow, reserve the right to change your mind, because a vow is precisely the sort of tossing of choice away that makes changing your mind irrelevant. When I spoke the words to my wife, that I would remain faithful to her, for richer or for poorer, in sickness and in health, as long as we both should live, I made a sacred vow. Did I know what that would entail? Of course not; hence the vow. We don't know whether we will be deliriously happy with the person we marry, or whether our lot will be trouble and suffering, or some all-too-human tragicomedy.
From Pseudogamy 106:
A culture of divorce, I'm suggesting, produces a lot of divorces, true, but mainly by producing a lot of people whom only a fool would trust. It makes everyone worse, because it attacks at the root the principal means by which the common person can do something godlike in its freedom and nobility: to cast one's lot forever with another human being, loving not by seeking one's own pleasure, but instead seeing that the greatest delight is only to be found in that freedom-tossing and therefore liberating love. It produces a culture of people who cannot be trusted with money, or with paper profits from supposed future investors, because they cannot even be trusted with rings; they are as good as their word when keeping their word profits them, or when breaking their word would cause them too much trouble. But make the price right, in money or in pleasure or in those vanities called "my dreams," and they can be bought out.
From Pseudogamy 107:
It is that we have come to consider permanence of any sort to be an affront to our beings, to our sovereign "choice". Which means that "culture," such as it is, is demoted to a smorgasbord to meet Mike's taste in Bach and Marty's taste in jazz, with nothing really to unite everyone in acts of general love or worship or celebration. Divorce, as I've written in an old article for Crisis magazine, is the sacrament for this new anti-state of affairs.
Marriage is more than "just a piece of paper", and there are very real differences between men and women. That many people have forgotten those truths or haven't learned them to begin with creates many problems for today's society.

Pseudogamy 108:

It occurs to me that the pseudogamy of the male homosexual is essentially related to the need to put on an act, an act that the man not burdened with same-sex attraction can hardly understand.

Most Efficient Video Defending Marriage

If you or someone you know wonders what the big deal is about neutering marriage (what some people call gay marriage or same-sex marriage) and why marriage should be defended from attempts to neuter it, you won't find a more efficient video than this one. The one thing I would have done differently is used a better example than drug laws.


Also, see my Reviewing the Basics entry at The Opine Editorials.

I'm not sure why embedded videos disappear from this blog. It's not like Blogger and YouTube are incompatible.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

We Are Your Family and Neighbors

Two of the statements we often hear from marriage neutering activists and homosexuality advocates in general are some variations of... 1) "We're your family, your neighbors, your friends, your coworkers, your teachers, your firefighters, your police officers, and your doctors." and 2) "We have contributed to providing products and services that you have used." While such statements might make the ignorant more aware that they have encountered homosexual people in the ordinary course of their lives, whether they know it or not, such statements are not good arguments for homosexual behavior or the necessity of neutering marriage licensing.

The first statement is a curious appeal to popularity - as if the popularity of something makes it good or true or necessitates action. I say "curious" because even the most strident homosexuality advocates know that people who identify as homosexuals, or consistently feel strong homosexual feelings are in the minority. So heterosexuality is more popular. Just because I have a family member or friend or professional associate who wants something doesn't mean I am obligated to give to them. While appealing to my concern for them as a fellow human being, the activist for change really is asking me to set aside my own convictions and feelings and to give up my vote to their cause. They are claiming to rest their happiness on my actions. If someone is relying on a marriage license to make them happy, they will be sorely disappointed, as many people have discovered.

Our government is there to protect the conditions that allow us to pursue happiness in an orderly society, not make us happy.

Regarding statement number 2: Since I, and most other people who recognize that marriage licensing should not be neutered, especially by courts, have never expressed a desire that homosexual people disappear, then I can only conclude that we are being asked to believe that because we make an exchange with someone for a good or service they provide, they believe we are obligated to offer moral, social, and political support for everything they do or want. But if that is the case, then why doesn't it work the other way around?

It matters not to me if a famous person is history or someone making great contributions to society today was or is a homosexual person. Homosexual behavior had little to no part in their societal contribution. What have they contributed to society that they couldn't if they have been completely celibate? Or engaged only in heterosexual behavior? As much as it rankles some people to hear, homosexual behavior, while it may be enjoyable for the individuals participating, contributes nothing positive to general society, but some forms of it are especially susceptible to spreading disease. Meanwhile, heterosexual behavior is how all of us got here – even test tube babies wouldn't be here if their ancestors hadn't engaged in heterosexual behavior. 

Which brings me to another reason those arguments aren't compelling. The same statements could be made of any number of other groups of people with a common cause or trait, including Bible-believers, marriage defenders, and people who value judicial restraint. I dare say, to the "gay" or "lesbian" who is reading this and believes their relationship with their partner should be licensed as marriage by the state – that there are people in your life you enjoy, love, respect, or count on in some way who believe that your relationship should not be licensed as marriage by the state, or even be called marriage on a social level. They may even think homosexual behavior is wrong. You may have no idea they feel this way – they are "in the closet", so to speak, at least around you. And if this is the case, it could be because you have demonstrated intolerance, and have loudly championed using the force of the courts to overturn their votes. If they have been civil enough to carry on their relationships with you, perhaps you should be civil enough not to cut them off if you discover they don’t agree with you. 

(This is a modified version of something I originally posted at The Opine Editorials)

Saturday, March 16, 2013

I Will Gladly Stay Out of Your Bedroom

I'm convinced that sex is for marriage and that sex or sex-like activity with someone other than one's spouse is harmful and wrong. However, I would not use the force of law to prevent consenting adults from doing whatever they want in private. Conversely, I do not think anyone should use the force of law to get me to pay for care necessitated by those activities. STDs? Injuries? Unplanned pregnancies? You consented, you can deal with it.

Many people who disapprove of homosexual behavior also defend marriage, and some marriage neutering advocates apparently have this is mind when they demand that we stay out of their bedrooms. In doing so, they are confusing the issues.

One need not disapprove of homosexual behavior to see the importance of resisting the neutering of state marriage licensing.

Maintaining marriage does not interfere in anyone's bedroom. Adults of any sexual orientation are legally free to engage in cohabitation, casual sex, and other sexual and general social interactions and voluntary arrangements.

A more relevant challenge is posed with something like this:
Who cares if a couple of guys want to marry each other?
Nothing is stopping consenting adults from sharing a home, bed, and life together; having showers and parties; entering into contracts (in some places, domestic partnerships); having a ceremony with consenting clergy, wearing dresses or tuxes, holding flowers, making vows, exchanging rings, stomping a glass; having a reception with gifts, a cake, bouquet-tossing, garter-tossing, and dancing through the night; taking a honeymoon vacation; changing names; calling themselves married; requesting that others consider them married; and celebrating anniversaries.

This had been going on before any state neutered marriage, it is all legally permitted, and there is no serious movement to pass legislation to change this.


It is when someone requests a marriage license (or a domestic partnership or civil union) from the government, which operates on behalf of the governed, that is when it becomes my business and the business of any citizen. State licensing is a public issue.


This isn't about what two people get to call their relationship - it is about forcing the rest of us to affirm brideless or groomless pairings as marriage, and preventing us from distinguishing between marriage and the pairing of two men or two women. The state is YOU and ME. It isn't as though, when the state issues a marriage license, it is "someone else".


We have seen the shift in activism go from "stay out of our lives" to "you must participate in our lives in the manner in which we demand." Well, I will gladly stay out of your bedroom. Please keep your hands off of my ballot.


(This is modified from a posting originally made at The Opine Editorials.)

Friday, March 15, 2013

Hasn't Marriage Always Been Changing?

This question or the idea behind it has been used by some to say that calling brideless or groomless pairing “marriage” would just be another change in something that has changed throughout history.

While there have been various restrictions on marriage (and the dissolution of marriages) through the centuries and around the world, and various ways people found a spouse, one of the only constants has been that marriage unites the two sexes. This has been true even in societies that did not consider homosexuality to be immoral or rare. Uniting the sexes is what makes marriage marriage. Mutual physical attraction or romantic love does not distinguish marriage from nonmarital relationships. Those things are not even required to obtain a marriage license, and if they had been what makes marriage marriage, than most marriages throughout history would not have been marriages from the start, such as many arranged marriages.

That something has undergone some changes over time does not require us to support any change that someone proposes.

A brideless or groomless pairing is simply not marriage. It is something else – something lacking the essence of marriage. It is no more marriage than a man is "gay" if he is, and has always been, attracted to women and not men, and never engages in homosexual behavior.

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Why Marriage is Different

The marriage debate has proven to be different than the general fight for “gay rights”, and this causing a lot of people to go bonkers, and exposing homofascist tendencies in some of them.

Why? Perhaps the answers can be found in recent history.

The "gay rights" movement has had astounding success. Homosexual behavior used to be illegal and was prosecuted. There were raids on places where homosexual people congregated. Homosexuality was classified as a disorder by the APA. Entertainers (and many others) hid homosexual behavior for fear of career loss. Kids were warned to beware of homosexuals, with such warnings equating them with pedophiles. Many people didn’t even know the word "homosexual".

Things have changed.

Is it Possible to Truly Achieve "Marriage Equality"?

Much of existing family law is predicated on marriage being something that involves both a husband and a wife, as it has been throughout history. If we are truly to have "marriage equality" so that the voluntary association of two men or two women must be treated, under law, exactly the same as natural marriage, I'm curious as to how this would work in the following areas:

Adoption – Same-sex couples would have just as much standing to adopt as a bride-groom couple, correct? Some people who devalue either masculinity or femininity, fatherhood or motherhood, and devalue sex-integration don't see this is a problem, but I think most people do, even if they support neutering state marriage licensing. This reality has meant that Catholic adoption agencies, in order to be true to their convictions, have had to cease operations in states with neutered licensing.

Paternity Assumption – In a bride-groom couple, for the protection of the child (and to keep the state from being on the hook for child support), the groom is considered the legal father by default of any child born to the bride. Would the non-carrying lesbian be considered the default parent of a child her partner carries, whether or not she agreed to the pregnancy, and regardless of how that pregnancy was accomplished? If not, then neither should a groom. Would a lesbian woman be held accountable if it turns out that her partner is secretly bisexual and turns up pregnant?

Child Custody - Women are often given preference over men in child custody matters, even when the man begs for custody. How would this work when it comes to same-sex couples who are being divorced? Would fathers being divorced from mothers gain more from this? Would the biological parent, if any, be favored? If not, what implications would that have when it comes to traditional stepfathers and stepmothers?

Child Support – Would the spouse who is not biologically related to the children still be forced to pay child support? It happens with bride-groom couples, but couldn't someone argue that they've never engaged in reproductive behavior and thus shouldn't be saddled with child support? If so, how could that argument be accepted while treating a groom being divorced from a bride equally (or will courts be forced to admit that homosexual sodomy and heterosexual coitus are not equivalent - and invade our bedrooms)? If there are two men, and one turns out to be bisexual or donates sperm, resulting in a pregnancy, is the other man's income to be included in figuring child support as happens when a bride and groom marry? (Yes, sperm donors have been held liable for child support.)

Abortion Rights - One woman gets pregnant, there is a split, the other woman - who has paid for the reproductive medical treatments, perhaps donated the eggs, and wants the children - sues to block abortion. Currently, a wife can get an abortion even if her husband objects. Will "gay rights" trump abortion rights? Oh, I can see the dilemma now! I suspect abortion rights will win that battle, especially if feminists realize that men could also use any precedent set.

Community Property was based on the idea that a marriage was creating a cooperative microcosm of society with a division of labor, more likely than not to raise children biologically related to both spouses, thereby perpetuating society. In order to treat all couples equally, would the concept of community property be diminished?

Alimony – Largely based on community property and division of labor, the concept has lost some importance with the equal access of women to the workplace. Again, would the concept of alimony be weakend? Surely, a man should not have to pay alimony because he married a woman while another man avoids paying it because he married another man? That wouldn't be equal.

Marriage Statistics - Would government agencies be allowed to collect, compile, and release statistics that distinguish between natural and neutered marriage? If not, marriage statistics could show marriage as being less favorable than they have in the past in terms of longevity (of the participants as well as the marriage), fidelity, domestic violence, poverty, mental health, positive effect on children, etc.

What has changed in Massachusetts and states that have subsequently neutered their licenses, and is the law still catching up? I don't see how we can neuter marriage licensing nationwide without it changing marriage for all, even those bride-groom couples who have been married for decades.

Remember – true equality works both ways. If highly noisy, persistent, and effective activist groups accomplish their goal of neutering marriage nationwide, what happens if they need to direct their energies to something new, especially if they discover things about state-licensed marriage that are not friendly to their subculture? I think we could kiss goodbye any hope of moving away from no-fault divorce. It would not surprise me if the "equality" groups were to subsequently demand taxpayer funding on-demand for all third-party reproduction. After all, many bride-groom couples can conceive for free. Shouldn't we correct this "inequality"?

I do not believe that the voluntary association of a man and a woman is the same kind of voluntary association as two women or two men, and I do not see a moral or legal obligation for the state to treat all three as the same. I see a state interest in licensing and encouraging natural marriage that is not met in either of the other two kinds of unions. It is obvious to me that what keeps same-sex "marriage" and natural marriage from being equal has less to do with state licensing requirement and more to do with the nature of the sexes and the differences between them.

The rights of children must be protected, as they do not consent to the circumstances of their birth, or the relationships their parents have. Whether marriage neutering gains or loses ground, we still have third-party reproduction, and something else should be put in place to protect the right of a child to both her mother and her father. Of course there will be instances in which, for the child's protection, access to one or both of her parents would have to be restricted or terminated, and redirected to an adoptive mother or father. But third-party reproduction has already deprived, by design, children of a mother or a father, and neutering marriage can only reinforce that.

Finally, is it really equality if there are still people who are prevented from marrying the other adults they love due to the circumstances of their birth or their sexual orientation? There are polyamorists who swear they are just as much polyamorist as they are gay, and cousins, who certainly didn't choose the circustances of their birth, who are not allowed to marry in many states. If marriage is based on the desires/feelings of the adults rather than the kind of union that can be procreative, what is the basis for limiting marriage licensing to just two particpants, or denying marriage licenses on the basis of consanguinity? Or, is marriage really based on the amount of hounding done by a lobby group?

(This is a modified version of a posting I originally published at The Opine Editorials.)

Monday, March 11, 2013

Why the Christian Focus on Homosexuality?

Royal Oaker, commenting on a post about the MSM lies about the PCUSA, wrote:

I don't see why Christians reserve so much hatred for gay people. You never see signs "God hates Divorced Persons!" or "God hates Adulterers!" like you see the perennial "God hates Phags!" There are rarely ever any articles written about how bad adulterers are, or divorced people, or women who have sex before marriage. Why are gay people always the victims of christian rage?

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Join Me on Facebook and Twitter

If you like to read my blog entries but wish I would update more often, friend me on Facebook and follow me on Twitter, where I update more frequently.

Saturday, March 9, 2013

What's With the Hate Over Moral Convictions?

It seems like a day doesn't go by that I don't see someone, whether in the MSM or one of my Facebook contacts, lashing out at pastors like Joel Osteen... with whom I have my own issues) or the Pope (I'm not a Roman Catholic myself), or someone running for President.

They are lashing out specifically because, given the Biblical teachings that sex is for marriage and that marriage unites a bride and a groom, these pastors and religious leaders and believers, when asked by people like Oprah about homosexual behavior, note that homosexual behavior, like all sex or sex-like behavior that isn't between spouses (spouses meaning bride with groom), is a sin. These people are being asked for what they believe, and they are being honest in their responses.
 
These pastors and religious leaders and believers are not advocating violence. They are stating what is found in the Bible and church tradition. If their conviction that sex outside of marriage is wrong is "hate speech" that somehow is a threat to you, how isn't your apparent conviction that their stating their convictions is wrong a threat to them?

None of these people are saying everyone has to find someone of the opposite sex and marry them. They aren't saying you don't feel what you feel.

So please... if you are such a person who hates or is angry at or disgusted by these pastors and religious leaders because they believe what they do about human sexuality (that 1. it is for marriage and 2. marriage unites a bride and groom), please, please, please enlighten me and anyone else like me:

1. Are there any moral restrictions when it comes to sex? If so, please explain what those restrictions are.

2. How did you discover or determine or learn what those morals are?

3. Why should Osteen, the Pope, me, or anyone else replace the morals we are convinced are right with the morals you hold?

I'd really like to know. You know, in case Oprah or some pageant judge with a bogus copycat name asks me.

Simply spewing hate at me or anyone else is not an argument. So don't even try it.

Keep in mind that if everyone were to adhere to the morals I list above, along with the principle that children have a natural right to a mother and  a father (so no using donations or reproductive technologies to intentionally bring children into a home without a mother or without a father) we would...

1. Have no children born out of wedlock (except in the rare cases of when a pregnant woman is widowed). Illegitimacy is correlated to many negative indicators.

2. Slash the rate of STD infections to almost nothing. Can we agree that STDs are bad?

3. Hack into small bits (there's a deliberate choice of words) the number of children slaughtered in the womb, or with their bodies out in the open but their head still in the canal. Come on, even you "pro-choicers" usually say that abortion isn't good in most cases.

4. Significantly reduce the heartache, depression, embarrassment, shame, and other negative feelings that come after someone has been fornicating with someone and the relationship ends.

5. Make it less likely that people who aren't compatible with or loving or respectful towards each other will drag their relationship on, possibly into marriage, only to split. Or do you think it is a good thing for people to stay with someone who makes them miserable just because they're having sex?

6. Continue the human race, with most children having had a parent of each of the two sexes to bond with, observe, and learn from, which is good considering every one of those children will have to interact with both men and women.

So... whatever alternate set of morals you offer should be at least as good in terms of results.

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Dancing With Primetime Politicking

With the new cast of "Dancing with the Stars" announced, I harken back to this entry I made at The Opine Editorials on April 6, 2010. It is a reminder of Dennis Prager's observations for for the Left, everything has to be political & sexual. There is no area of life where the Left refrains from invoking those topics.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Is It the End of the World As We Know It?

And do we feel fine?

Seriously, Obama was re-elected, there's a push for more gun control, the Pope has announced his resignation, and the Kardashians are all over television. These and other current events are being cited by some of my Christian brothers and sisters as signs that soon, true believers will disappear from the planet, a one-world government will form led by a man who is the Antichrist, a deal will be made with the present-day secularized nation of Israel, and later war will be waged against said nation, and after seven years of very bad things, Jesus Christ will return to reign as King for an actual calendar 1,000 years, and after some other stuff happens, then we'll get a New Heaven and New Earth.

Full disclosure: The only things I'm convinced about when it comes to the future are:

1) Our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ will physically return in power and glory to judge everyone.
2) We'll have a "new Heaven and new Earth" where the problems of sin, sickness, death, deterioration, and decay will be done away with.
3) Those who are in Christ will have glorified, imperishable bodies and will fellowship with Him.
4) Those unrepentant, unredeemed sinners who do not have Jesus Christ as their Lord will suffer apart from that fellowship.

I know premillenniallism with a pre-Tribulational Rapture is very popular view of the future now, depicted in the extremely popular Left Behind series and promoted by Hal Lindsey and many other popular Christian writers/television preachers (and somewhat in "The Omen" series of feature movies), but in current form, it doesn't go all that far back in church history. That doesn't make it wrong, but I'm not convinced it is right, nor am I convinced any form of post-millennialism or "amillennialism" or "partial preterism" is right; some say everything prophesied in the Bible except for the four things I listed above were fulfilled in the first century and nothing else has to happen before "the end of the world" and judgment for all. For anyone who IS certain that their eschatalogical view is right, well, fine... but the experts thought they knew exactly how things were going to be the first time Messiah came around, and most of them were wrong. I don't know with certainty which view is right, other than the four things I listed, on which all views agree.

Please understand that my only dog in this fight is the truth, and glorifying Jesus Christ, and communicating the Gospel to the world. I do not think it glofires Christ to set dates for His return, try to pin the tail on the Antichrist, or decry new technologies as "the Mark of the Beast". If Jesus Christ is your Lord & Savior and you are His follower and you refuse to deny Him, you already HAVE the mark of The Lamb and no chip or bar code or triple digit number is going to pry you from the Holy Spirit.

I don't see why the partial-preterists AND the furists can't BOTH be right. Why can't Nero be considered an Antichrist and why can't we still have another one to come? Why can't events in the first century be seen as a Great Tribulation and yet we still will have a Great Tribulation in the future? It would not be the first time that prophecy had more than one fulfillment. The Bible is full of repeating types and shadows and things that had a valid meaning intended for the original audience as well as a later audience.

I'm not convinced the USA must terminally decline NOR that our Lord has made any promise to preserve the USA. I oppose world government because I support limited government and competition. I support Israel for political reasons, in so far as the actions of the government are just. I live like today could be the end (because it could be... for any one of us, if not for the whole world), but I plan as though I'm going to live this life into the triple digits and that my kids will have to live on after me, and that we could face some very rough times along the way. I work to make life better - if it will get worse, so be it, but it won't be because I threw up my hands and gave up. As long as I'm clinging to Jesus, I will go where He goes, when He goes there.

Please, please, please... plan like you and your children and grandchildren will live long lives in this world, because there's no guarantee things will change sooner rather than later, and be spiritually prepared for this to be your last day of this life, because it just may be. We, as individuals and as the world, are not guaranteed another day. I focus on God like today could be my last day of this life – because it could be, even if it is the end of my life but not the end of the world. But I also need to plan and work as though I’ll have to take care of myself and my family for the rest of the century. I have thrown myself on His mercy, because I have sinned against Him. I look to Jesus Christ as my Lord and Savior, recognizing that He paid for my sins on the cross.

Monday, February 11, 2013

My State of the Union 2013 Wish List

I know most of these positions will be completely avoided by President Obama, never mind that they wouldn't have a chance of being implemented with the current Senate, even with a Republican POTUS.  But permit me to dream. Also notice that with most of these, I'm calling on the President to encourage action by the people, not to use the force of law.

Explain That the Federal Government Is Not the Answer to Every Challenge, Problem, or Choice - Rather, it is the Last Resort Answer to Very Few. That is what freedom and liberty are all about.  Challenge individuals, businesses, congregations, nonprofits, and local and state governments (where appropriate) to take action instead of relying on the federal government. The federal government is there to protect the union from foreign threats and to and resolve some disputes between states.

Tout the Successes of the War on Terror. Laud those military, intelligence, and law enforcement personnel who have uncovered and prevented terrorist plans and actions, pointing out that is has been over eleven years since terrorists have carried out a major attack in the U.S. Apologize for Benghazi and what happened in the wake of that terrorist attack.

Border Control Is a Matter of National Security. Explain that allow illegal aliens any advantage in gaining permanent legal status ahead of legal immigrants is a slap in the face to legal immigrants and naturalized citizens. Announce that, effective immediately, the National Guard will secure our borders to prevent terrorists, disease-carriers, and smugglers from entering the U.S. They will stay there until suitable barriers and checkpoints are constructed – however long that takes. We will NOT encourage further invasion by offering amnesty, health insurance, and other tax-funded benefits for citizens of other countries who illegally enter/stay in the U.S. Speed up the process for legal immigration for those who want to come to the U.S. legally to become citizens and can find sponsors who will ensure they will stay off of public assistance. As for illegal aliens currently living in the United States – do not offer amnesty; they can go through the same channels of those who are trying to immigrate legally. If the border is secure, this problem will eventually take care of itself because their children born here are citizens and the illegals can continue to function as they have until they die off, if they don't want to go the legal route. Any illegal alien who serves honorably in the U.S. armed forces should be granted citizenship. If a true shortage of labor occurs (meaning American unemployment is low and employers need more temporary labor), a true guest worker program can be developed.

Break the Street Gangs. Pledge federal agencies to assist state and local law enforcement "sweep and hold" gang-infested urban areas.

Encourage Responsible Gun Ownership. As it is the duty of every able person to stand up to evil & crime in protection of the innocent, responsible gun ownership, training, and practice should be encouaged, and state and local laws should allow for this. Apologize for Fast & Furious.

Declare That the Lack of a Budget, the Large Deficit, and the Growing National Debt Unacceptable. Explain that it is a basic function of the federal government to adopt a budget, and that it is unsustainable and immoral to accumulate increasing debt, thereby burdening future generations. The government should not encourage further dependency on government.
Don't be Santa Claus. Don't propose new federal programs and expansions of existing federal social programs. Enough already. There are 50 states in the union and a few territories that are supposed to be handling their own matters – that is, the matters that are not supposed to be left up to "the people".

Stop Using the Tax Code For Social Engineering. Tell the Congress that instead of taking the carrots (taxes) from the people and then dangling some of them back in front of the people, that the people should keep their carrots in the first place and do with them what they will. Call for tax simplification and a move away from income/payroll taxes. If someone pays taxes, everyone should pay taxes.

Individuals Should Plan for the Future. Talk about the numerous options individuals and families have for saving for the future. Encourage them to save and invest for the future and not rely on the federal government to take care of them in their senior years. Point out that a reduction in federal spending will allow people to keep more of their own money to aid in saving for retirement.

Explain that Planning for Your Health Care is Part of Planning for the Future. Call for more freedom, competition, and private decision-making in health care.

Equal Access to Free Markets. Explain some of the major benefits of free markets, and that the best thing the federal government can do to foster a good business climate that provides jobs is to provide protection from interstate crime and foreign terrorists, and to be involved as little as possibly in voluntary employment and business transactions, not picking winners or losers in business, subsidizing some and restricting upstarts while protecing established businesses.

Property Rights and Personal Freedom. Most Americans understand that people should be considered as individuals and based on their behavior and abilities, not as members of a non-ideological group (ethnicity, etc.). Therefore, the federal government should no longer be involved in preventing people from renting, selling - or not - to whomever they choose for whatever reason, and should no longer be involved with who an employer hires and fires and why. Airlines, for example, should not be forced to carry anyone who makes the majority of their employees and passengers uncomfortable. It is clear that people can succeed in the USA regardless of skin color, sex, or sexual orientation, and focusing on slights, imagined or real, based on these personal characteristics, is fostering hostility and division and self-defeating thinking, doing more harm than good.

Encourage private innovation and solutions to reducing reliance on terrorist oil.

Education Is a Private Responsibility. Given the state of American public education since the Carter administration, call for the dismantling of federal involvement in education.

Strong Marital Unions Are Good For the Union. It brings together both sexes to raise the next generation of citizens. Men and women are different, and unifying them in the marital union forms a strong, inclusive building block for society, benefiting the individuals and society. Call on the Federal government to help by continuing to affirm, as Presidents Clinton and Bush did, that marriage unites a man and a woman, and pledge that the federal government will not force states to recognize counterfeit marriages. Encourage people to voluntarily take marriage seriously, thinking for the long term, getting good pre-marital counseling - and counseling during marriage as necessary. Encourage individuals, families, congregations, businesses, and the media to respect and value marriage, and support marriages instead of undermining them. Encourage individuals to save sex and childrearing for marriage, because doing so is good for them and good for the country.

Encourage Proven Conservation Techniques. Quote the scientists and activists who, in the 1970s, warned that we were heading for a new ice age, and quote those who said that by 2000, the rainforests and the oceans would be destroyed. Go on to say that we must not hastily and uncritically accept alarmist warnings and use federal government force to impose destructive restrictions on the people and business that may not result in significant environmental benefit.

Civility. Call on partisans to vigorously debate the issues, but refrain from threats of violence and character assassination, as they renew their vow to defend the Constitution.

Saturday, January 26, 2013

It is Natural For a Child to Have and Want a Mommy


There are men out there, some partnered with other men, raising children the best they know how. If the choice is institutionalization or a two-man home (the men being generally good people), then I go with the two-man home. God bless people who choose to rescue children from institutionalization.

What I do NOT support is when unmarried people or same-sex couples intentionally create a situation through "third party" reproduction in which a child will be condemned to motherless or fatherless lives, or adopt infants or other children that could easily be places in a bride+groom home.

Rob Watson, LGBT activist, demonstrates why.
I always figured there were certain hateful statements that my sons would make, especially ones that say I am inadequate.
Hateful. Really?
I rushed him to the nearby bathroom as the stomach convulsions continued, and we experienced one of what would be many rounds of this illness episode. It was a horrible event, because there was nothing I could do for him but hold him while his body expelled the contents of his stomach. He cried and gasped and tried to recover.

"I am so so sorry," I whispered as his body tensed again.

"I want my mommy," he cried out, bursting into tears!

Say what?!
He... wants... his... mommy.
However, his comment was still concerning, because there is no such person in his life, nor has there ever been. He has been in my arms since he was 4 days old and weighed 4 lbs. There was a birth mother, but she was not a "mommy" and has never been there for him.

Yes, but he knows other kids have their Mommy.
I tried to ignore the comment, and I pet him gently. I had to say something, though, and I heard myself muttering, "You have a daddy, and I am here, boo."

He looked up and cried, "But you aren't my mom!"

Now I was at the emotional edge.
You were at the emotional edge?

"You have a dad, boo, not a mom," I said. "I do all your mom things for you. A mom just does what I do but would be a girl. I am your mom. Try to relax. You will feel better in a minute."

He looked at me again and cried out, "I want Papa!" Papa is my ex and was my co-parent for the boys. He chose to keep his distance from us over the past year.
Lovely. How fun for the kids.
The fact was that nothing could magically give my son comfort in that moment. I was not going to be able to make that happen. He knew it, and I knew it, and in his hypoglycemic irrationality he was lashing out in any way his mind could muster.

It is natural for a child to want his mother.
For me, the drama would continue: My younger son also got hit with the illness, so my new partner Jim took care of one child in one bathroom while I took care of the other child in another bathroom.

Oh, great. Just like heterosexual people who keep introducing their new lovers to their kids. More chaos. At least with heterosexual couples there are stepmothers as well as stepfathers. These children will not have a female parent with whom to bond and learn from, and yes, there IS a difference. Gender makes a difference to Watson in his relationships. Gender makes a difference in parental relationships, too.

The entire adventure is now a thing for our family history book, under "Thanksgiving Disasters," but still I felt the nagging residual pang of sadness over my son's declaration. I finally talked to him recently, and the conversation affirmed that he is not feeling that he is lacking anything with only male parents in our family.
He's going to tell you what you want to hear. He has no idea what he's truly missing, other than missing a mother.
He explained that one of his school friends talks to him "in private" and tries to tell him that he needs his "real" mother, and this friend has tried to get him on sites to "find" her. 

It is none of that other person's business, but biology makes it clear that there was a biological mother at some point. The writer might as well blame it on a biology textbook. Adopted children sometimes latch on to fantasies of other parents, but at least when there's both a mother and father present, they can honestly say we are your mother and father.
I do not believe that children of all ages should be privy to the intimate details of adult relationships, but they do need enough information to know that many family structures exist, thrive and are equal to their own.
How is a one-parent family equal to a two parent family? It isn't - not for the kid. How is a motherless pairing equal to a gender-inclusive pairing? It isn't - not for the kid. Saying they are all equal doesn't make it so. They are objectively different.


I fully support the freedom of association. If someone wants to pair with someone of the same sex (or for a triad, or whatever) that should be entirely up to them. Have ceremonies/parties/vacations, change your names, exchange jewelry, so on and so forth. Children do not have the freedom of association, and when activism pushes aside the needs of children in the quest for popular affirmation of private behavior, that is where the line is drawn.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

The Orange Analogy

One of the primary functions of government is the continuance of the nation or state. As such, it has an interest in human reproduction, especially reproduction that happens naturally and is the result of normal, natural, common behavior between two citizens.

One of the primary functions of a grocer is to sell food; a produce seller sells produce (fruits and vegetables). A common item a produce seller sells is oranges.

But not everybody likes oranges. Some people are downright allergic.

Let's say most of these people are intensely drawn to playing with an orange rubber ball (ORB).

They insist the produce seller sell ORBs.

"I have no interest in selling ORBs, I am here to sell oranges," says the produce seller (PS).

"But we don't like oranges," says the activist group (AG) that likes ORBs.

PS: "Okay, well then, you don't have to buy oranges."

AG: "But we're here in the store. We have a right to participate in buying. We're no less human beings than your other customers."

PS: "I didn’t say you were. I'm here to sell oranges. ORBs are not oranges."

AG: "What's the difference? ORBs are round and orange, just like oranges."

PS: "But they're not food. I sell oranges because people eat them."

AG: "Not every orange that gets bought gets eaten. Some that get bought are too old, or are rotten, or infested. Some get destroyed. Some are used for decoration."

PS: "But most oranges are eaten. I sell them in this produce store because they are food. ORBs are not food. Oranges satisfy hunger and provide nutrition to the body."

AG: "But I saw that shopper right there buying oranges in here buying oranges several times before. How satisfying can they be?"

PS: "That doesn’t change the fact that oranges are food, and ORBs are not."

AG: "Some orange buyers also buy ORBs. Some do it under the table."

PS: "That doesn't change the fact that oranges are food and ORBs are not. Why should I sell ORBs?"

AG: "To make money. Selling ORBs will financially benefit the store and make us happy."

PS: "Fine! Okay!!! I will sell them elsewhere in the store."

AG: "Make them the same price."

PS: "Okay! Whatever you want."

AG: "Now put the ORBs in the orange bin, and sell them together."

PS: "But they're not oranges; they’re not food!"

AG: "It isn't about food. It is about selling things to people. Putting the ORBs in the orange bin and calling them oranges won't hurt the oranges."

PS: "ORBs do not provide nutrition."

AG: "There's enough nutrition in the world. Besides, we can put peanut butter on the ORBs and get nutrition that way. Sell the ORBs as oranges."

PS: "No! Look, I polled my customers, and the majority do not want that."

AG: "We're taking you to court."

The management of the produce store does not want to bother with court. Fans of Oranges (FOO), a customer group, decides to defend distinguishing oranges from ORBs in the store.

Judge: "Because the store sells both oranges and ORBs, and agreed to sell ORBs at the same price, it has to sell the ORBs from the orange bin, labeled as oranges."

Orange-buying customer: "I hate people who play with ORBs."

FOO: "That's irrelevant and you're not helping."

AG: "See! The only reason not to sell ORBs as oranges is hate!"

Judge: "You, FOO, have not demonstrated through legal evidences that oranges are different than ORBs. I mean, even though I don't buy oranges and I like ORBs, you haven't proven legally there's a difference. People get nutrition without buying oranges. People eat oranges without buying them in the store. Oranges are more prestigious than ORBs. This hurts the feelings of those who don't like oranges, but like ORBs. ORB-lovers have been hated. So I rule that produce sellers must sell ORBs as oranges."

...and that's how orange rubber calls, by court order, will be labled as oranges.

Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Domestic Partnerships and Civil Unions are Trojan Horses

As another state considers going this route, I understand why other marriage defenders are against civil unions on principle. They see it as something that devalues marriage, much as most of them see shacking up and societal acceptance of fornication as well as shacking up as devaluing marriage. Many of these people want to discourage homosexual behavior as detrimental. I, too, see homosexual behavior as detrimental and civil unions as devaluing marriage. However, I recognize that people are going to do what they're going to do behind closed doors, and with broad societal accommodation, most people with homosexual feelings are not going to consider enough incentive to refrain from homosexual behavior. So, I see civil unions as a compromise to give same-sex couples a shortcut to certain legal arrangements, even though those arrangements were attached to marriage because of marriage's procreative and uniting-of-the-sexes nature. I want to be a nice guy. I don't see civil unions as a right, but would be willing to support a law creating them... except that I can't due to tactical reasons. Instead of preserving marriage law (which is why - along with discouracing homosexual promiscuity - I'd be willing to support them even though I think they devalue marriage somewhat), civil unions are used as a Trojan Horse to neuter marriage licensing. Once they are in place, the battle cry of the marriage neutering crowd becomes "we can't have 'seperate but equal'". Of course, the courts should recognize that civil unions are for associations that are inherently different than marriage, but Judge Walker didn't in the California Propostion 8 case.

I would think it good if DOMA was replaced by a Constitutional amendment that made a distinction between marriage and civil unions, thus allowing the federal government to recognize neutered marriage licenses from the states that issue them, and civil unions from the states that issue those – for things like federal employees and such, while preventing states from being forced to neuter their marriage licenses. The problem is, what matters more to marriage neutering advocates, more than getting certain legal entitlements, is removing all distinctions made between marriage and this form of non-marriage, so such an amendment would not satisfy them. In their thinking, marriage must be killed and replaced by a counterfeit, or SSM.

This blog entry, originally at The Opine Editorials a while back, was prompted by coverage of the Trojan Horse in Hawaii. Reporting by Suzanne Roig, writing by Dan Whitcomb, editing by Greg McCune brought this Reuters article.
Governor Neil Abercrombie on Wednesday signed into law a bill allowing same-sex civil unions, making Hawaii the seventh U.S. state to grant essentially the same rights as marriage to gay couples.
So the law is like California's domestic partnerships, where both-sexes couples need not apply unless at least one of them is a senior citizen?
"This signing today of this measure says to all the world that they are welcome, that everyone is a brother or a sister in paradise."
Wait, did he just compare SSM to incest? That's outrageous! Hawaii has a history of recognizing brother-sister marriages as valid, unlike brideless or groomless pairings. So making the comparison is a bad thing to do.
"The legalization of civic unions in Hawaii represents in my mind, equal rights," Democrat Abercrombie said in signing the measure, his first as governor.
Yeah, and that's what marriage neutering proponents say for a while, until the Trojan Horse is in the door. Then, suddenly, the civil union law they said was so vital becomes an insult.
"Today marks a big step toward full equality for lesbian and gay people in the Aloha state," said Jennifer Pizer, national marriage project director for the gay rights group Lambda Legal.
Big step forward? What, pray tell, is left? I think we all know the answer to that.
Here's an Associated Press article by Mark Niesse.
For years, the Rev. Fay Hovey has held romantic ceremonies on the sand for gay partners who want to pledge their love in Hawaii.
How is that possible? Marriage neutering advocates, including the ones in the news media, have told us that such things were banned! Do they think we can't compare articles from the same news agencies?

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

A Different Marriage Pledge

We've heard of pledges politicians have been asked to sign that affirm, among other things, the bride+groom core of marriage.

We know marriage neutering advocates would never sign a pledge like that. However, they should be asked to sign a different marriage pledge. This one should be a pledge to:

1) Oppose with statements, votes, and vetoes any attempt to a) provide legal recognition to polygamous or incestuous marriages; b) lower the age consent; or c) grant person status to machines or nonhuman animals.

2) Support with statements, votes, and votoes the rights of a) clergy, religious venues, and religious organizations not to perform or host wedding ceremonies in violations of their principles; and b) the rights of parents to teach their children that a marriage only exists when bride and a groom are involved.

Since so many marriage neutering advocates publicly scoff (to the point of being bullies) at the idea that neutering marriage can be in any way associated with polygamy, incest, pedophilia, or bestiality, and since they have said "churches won't be forced to perform same-sex ceremonies", they should have no problems signing such a pledge, right?

Of course, if they are willing to sign a pledge with the first point, they will be admitting that marriage should be defined one way and not another, and that there isn't a fundamental right to marry or define it any way someone wants, since they would be opposing marriages (polygamous, incestuous) that have been historically recognized and are currently practiced and recognized in various parts of the world. They would be admitting that it is okay to place restrictions on marriage licensing for the sake of good public policy over personal desires.

Friday, December 28, 2012

Simple Reason I Never Bought Into Birther Conspiracy

All (or at least most) of the people who buy into the idea that President Obama is somehow ineligible to serve as President due to his birth also believe that the Clintons (or someone backing the Clintons) literally murdered a bunch of people before and during President Clinton's terms as President.

If Obama was actually ineligible, HRC surely would have had access to that information and used that information to secure the nomination in 2008.

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Dang It

Yeah, I know that people who defend the bride+groom requirement in marriage licensing sometimes send in letters that are less than stellar. Time and time again, though, I see this letters like this one from Dang Dinh of Fullerton, California, submitted to the Orange County Register:
Marriage is about more than procreation; therefore, gay couples should not be denied the right to marry because of biology [“Supreme Court will review Prop. 8,” Front Page, Dec. 10].
Cars are about more than driving; therefore, someone who won't drive should not be denied the right to a driver's license.
It is inaccurate to perceive marriage merely as an institution for child-raising purposes.
Correct. It is intrinsically about uniting the two sexes by joining a bride and groom. It is the ability and tendency of such unions to naturally produce new citizens that gives the state an interest it does not have with other kinds of voluntary associations.
Many married couples in society today do not have children of their own, often by choice.
Irrelevant.
They marry because marriage symbolizes a long-term commitment to one another, not a pledge to reproduce for the state or for humanity as a whole.
Irrelevant. People can commit to each other without a state license.
In any case, gay couples may adopt children in countries where they are permitted to do so, revealing society’s view at large that homosexual couples can readily act as capable parents and provide loving home environments.
No couples missing one of the sexes provides a child with both a mother and a father. All children will grow up to deal with both men and women, and having a parent of each of the two sexes is beneficial for preparing them for this. and thus is the preferable relationships for raising children. If homosexual couples have to be treated equally to inclusive, married couples, then adoption agencies will be unable to function according to this ideal.
Furthermore, the advance of medical science has also enabled same-sex couples to have children of their own through surrogate mothers and sperm donors.
Bad idea. It's also a bad idea when unmarried heterosexual people do that.
It can no longer be said that homosexual couples should not be granted the right to marriage because, either, they cannot have children or that they cannot raise children adequately. Both claims are false.

That's not my argument. My argument is that bride+groom couples are objectively, demonstrably different, and can provide government documents attesting to this, than a brideless couple or a groomless couple, and that it is Constitutional to treat different kinds of voluntary associations differently.

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Marriage Equality

Oh, it's so confusing!

Marriage neutering advocates have been saying that there is NO DIFFERENCE between brideless couples, groomless couples, and bride+groom couples, and demanding equal treatment for all three.

However, British policymakers are wrestling with how brideless or groomless marriages would be legally consummated, since that still matters in British law.

Since it's all about "equality" why not leave the consummation requirements exactly as they've always been... hmmmmmmm? Wouldn't that be equal treatment?


 

Saturday, December 1, 2012

God Doesn't Lead By Polls

The Los Angeles Times ran a commentary, as the paper is prone to do, in which someone warned that churches need to stop teaching the Bible if they want to stay relevant. This one was written by Robert D. Putnam, a professor of public policy at Harvard University, and David E. Campbell, a professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, the  authors of American Grace: How Religion Divides and Unites Us.

The most rapidly growing religious category today is composed of those Americans who say they have no religious affiliation.
Well, yeah. When 95% of a group identifies as either A, B, C, or D, then the 5% who identify as E will grow 100% if it numbers switch to 90%-10%.

While middle-aged and older Americans continue to embrace organized religion, rapidly increasing numbers of young people are rejecting it.
Guess what? Young people tend to get older. They tend to get married and have kids, and get more serious about religious identity.

As recently as 1990, all but 7% of Americans claimed a religious affiliation, a figure that had held constant for decades. Today, 17% of Americans say they have no religion, and these new "nones" are very heavily concentrated among Americans who have come of age since 1990.
So 83% claim an affiliation. If 83% of scientists say they believe in manmade global warming, if 83% of voters were to say they support abortion-on-demand being legal and taxpayer funded, if 83% of voters were in favor of neutering state marriage licensing, it would be call an "overwhelming majority" and dissenters would be portrayed as crackpots. Perhaps people in the past who claimed an affiliation were not regular churchgoers or people who practiced a religion, and young people are refusing to pick an affiliation out of honesty?

So, why this sudden jump in youthful disaffection from organized religion?
Assuming the premise of your question is true… it might have something to do with the rabid militarism of secular humanism or moral relativism in the public square and public institutions.

The surprising answer, according to a mounting body of evidence, is politics.
Here's where they get to the point of their commentary, which is to tell us that we should stop taking religion seriously when deciding which political issues are important to us and how we vote.

Very few of these new "nones" actually call themselves atheists, and many have rather conventional beliefs about God and theology. But they have been alienated from organized religion by its increasingly conservative politics.
Organized religion is hardly getting more conservative politically. It is that the Leftists are finding it harder to move the country Leftward.

During the 1980s, the public face of American religion turned sharply right.
What happened was that people woke up and realized that staying out of politics and letting the elitists, ivory tower hermits, and hedonists run everything was becoming a huge problem.

Political allegiances and religious observance became more closely aligned, and both religion and politics became more polarized.
Politicians are more likely to be seen speaking in liberal churches.

Abortion and homosexuality became more prominent issues on the national political agenda, and activists such as Jerry Falwell and Ralph Reed began looking to expand religious activism into electoral politics.
Why don't these commentaries every bring up Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, etc.?

Church attendance gradually became the primary dividing line between Republicans and Democrats in national elections.
Yes, Democrats should really get to church more often.

Some Americans brought their religion and their politics into alignment by adjusting their political views to their religious faith. But, surprisingly, more of them adjusted their religion to fit their politics.
You mean the liberal churches, who abandon the Bible in favor of political correctness?

But a majority of the Millennial generation was liberal on most social issues, and above all, on homosexuality. The fraction of twentysomethings who said that homosexual relations were "always" or "almost always" wrong plummeted from about 75% in 1990 to about 40% in 2008.
Gee, I can't imagine why, given what they are bombarded with the media and academia.

If being religious entailed political conservatism, they concluded, religion was not for them.
Religion is good as a social club and motivational exercise, but when the logical application of religious teachings means not forcing other people to pay your way through life and saving sex for marriage, well, that's just too much.

Continuing to sound the trumpet for conservative social policy on issues such as homosexuality may or may not be the right thing to do from a theological point of view, but it is likely to mean saving fewer souls.
From a Christian perspective, you are not saving souls at all if people don't have Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. He's not Lord if you don't let Him lead when it comes to sexuality.

More likely is that as growing numbers of young Americans reject religious doctrine that is too political or intolerant for their taste, innovative religious leaders will concoct more palatable offerings.
This has been going on since the beginning of time. People want to mold God in their image, rather than being transformed to following the will of God. There are plenty of churches that cater to the former, and they are the ones who are dying. Bible-teaching churches, like my own, are growing. You think I like everything in every sermon? Nope. It would feel great to have the minister say that everything I'm doing is okay and I don't need to change a thing about how I live my life. But the minister would be lying.

The Gospel is offensive, because it requires that people recognize they are sinners that there is a Lord and His way is the only right way. I agree that we need to be gentle and respectful and relevant when presenting the Gospel and making disciples and ministering to the needy, but there is no compromising when it comes to the truth.

Previously [Townhall links might not work]:

Losing Their Religion
Evangelical Collapse
Are You Ready For Post-Christian America?
Steamed Rice
On the Manhattan Declaration
On Jesus, the Bible, and the Religious Right