Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Abdicating Your Vote to Teenagers

Some marriage neutering advocates proclaim inevitability because of fauxmentum based on poll dancing and talking with teenagers. For example, one morning I was listening to Los Angeles-based talk radio host Bill Handel who was citing that younger generations don’t see what the issue is – why wouldn’t a man be able to get a state marriage license with another man? He used his own westside-of-LA-raised teenaged daughters as an example. There is probably some truth to that – teenagers haven’t matured enough and experienced enough life to understand the implications of the differences between the sexes and what marriage is and isn’t, and what it means and how it has an impact on individuals, families, and the community.

However, we don’t determine public policy based on the feelings and inexperienced, uninformed opinions of teenagers. Otherwise, we might replace Algebra, Biology, and History classes with porn screenings (they have to wait for university for that), eliminate curfews, lower the drinking, smoking, and driving age to 13 along with the age of consent for sex, and excuse stealing, lying, and cheating as long as it was for a teen’s short-term gain. Your child might not understand why you say “no” to a sleepover – it doesn’t mean you relent. Children do tend to grow up, and grow more socially conservative as they get older, marry, and have children of their own. (Having children of both sexes does much to educate many people on the differences between the sexes, if marriage hasn't already. Many boys are drugged essentially because they are not girls.) Some children need more help in understanding the realities of life than others, and it is up to their parents, first and foremost, to teach them.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Purposes and the Meaning of Words

Marriage is the one institution, the one voluntary association in which the Left or certain gender activists are okay with excluding women. Just try to form a legally sanctioned association while openly barring women from joining. Won’t be allowed. Unless that association is a marriage. The same lawyer who sues to force a male organization to accept women will sue to allow women to exclude men from a marriage. Why? Leftism is feelings-based, and the feelings of women and "minorities" are more important than those of white heterosexual men.

Great analogies are difficult for this topic because marriage is unique - at least, it is suppossed to be. That is part of the current issue at hand. I am convinced it is important to keep the legal definition of marriage in line with what human history universally demonstrated: marriage unites the sexes.

The issue is so polarizing now that it is difficult to convince the other side we're not bigots and do not hate people who identify as gay or lesbian or consider them less than worthy of having their rights protected. But I like to try.

Monday, June 10, 2013

Yes, Defending Marriage is Discrimination

Those of us who oppose marriage neutering are often accused of supporting discrimination.

I'd like to confess.

I'm guilty as charged.


Yes, defending marriage involves discrimination.

But those pushing to neuter marriage, or as they would put it, pushing for "marriage equality" – they discriminate as well in everything, including their position on marriage licensing.

The truth is, we all discriminate. We couldn't function if we didn't. We discriminate against staying in bed longer or getting up earlier. We discriminate between eating this or eating that. We discriminate in whether or not to ask any given person for a date or whether or not to accept a request for a date. In decisions large and small, we discriminate - and we should. In addition, all of our laws discriminate - separating what is legal from what is illegal.

So, yes, defending marriage is discrimination, but not illegal, unfair, immoral, arbitrary, or unconstitutional discrimination.

What our laws can't Constitutionally - and shouldn't - do is discriminate against individuals on the basis of their ethnicity, sex (with some exceptions), or, in many places, sexual orientation.

Bride+groom marriage licensing doesn't. Nor does neutered marriage licensing. But the burden of proof in most states and at the federal level, rests on those who are pushing to neuter marriage to show that bride+groom marriage licensing unconstitutionally discriminates, necessitating a change.

They have failed to do so. That an individual does not want to participate in something to which he or she has access does not mean the access isn't there.

Note that even neutered marriage licensing still discriminates – against groups of three or more, individuals who are already married to other people, couples consisting of close relatives, and so forth.

Setting some criteria for state licensing of anything is appropriate and constitutional. Marriage defenders usually have just one more criterion than the marriage neutering advocates – that both sexes are represented in this voluntary association that is seeking public sanction as marriage.

(This is modified from an entry originally posted at The Opine Editorials.)

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Equal Protection

I have written about what I consider to be bad arguments that are frequently used to advocate marriage neutering, or against legislation that codifies again (or restores) bride+groom state marriage licensing.

But there is one argument that marriage neutering advocates make that seems to be their strongest, at least in the U.S.A. It is some variation of an appeal to "equal access/protection". It packs the most emotional punch, given the desire of the average American to support “equality”.

But law is about logic and facts, not emotion.

Equal protection is a concept found in the federal Constitution, in the Fourteenth Amendment. In Section 1, is this text:
No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Emphasis mine. Notice that this applies to individuals. A simple reading of the text reveals that it does not apply to couples or any groupings. Under traditional marriage licensing, where both a bride and a groom are required, is there equal access (and therefore, protection) provided to homosexual individuals in relation to straight individuals?

Yes. Any man, regardless of sexual orientation, is allowed to be a groom. Any woman, regardless of sexual orientation, is allowed to be a bride. Both men and women have equal access to marriage licensing.


I understand that some individuals do not want to marry someone of the opposite sex, and want to get a marriage licensing with someone of the same sex. However, that someone wants something other than what is available does not mean what is offered denies equal protection and must be changed.

 
It is worth noting that under neutered marriage licensing, where the bride-groom requirement is absent, it is still equal protection as heterosexual individuals are also allowed to get licenses with someone of the same sex. However, any domestic partnership or civil union law that excludes male-female pairings while applying to same-sex couples denies equal protection to some couples. I do not have a problem with this, as I note it is Constitutional to treat different kinds of voluntary associations differently, and thus marriage applies to bride-groom couplings while domestic partnerships and civil unions can be applied to other kinds of couplings.


If, despite the plain text of the Fourteenth Amendment, one argues that equal protection must also be extended to couples instead of individuals only, such a change would have profound effects on many areas of law beyond marriage licensing. Suddenly, pairings/partnerships will have rights previously only recognized as applying to individuals. Such a change should require implementation by Amendment, but sadly, I think it is possible a court will create it by decision.


If equal protection must be extended to pairings, then doesn't that also mean presumably platonic pairings, such as business partners, partners in crime (especially those who do not want to testify against each other), roommates, friends, and siblings? And where is the justification to limit the equal protection to pairings instead of trios or larger groupings? A businessperson can form two different partnerships with to different partners. Under "equal protection for couples", surely we can't deny a bigamist what he or she wants.


While appealing to "fairness" and insisting that it is what they want and it would make them happy may be emotionally effective in manipulating public sentiment, the "equal protection" argument does not stand up to scrutiny from a Constitutional perspective. Individuals are allowed to pursue what they want, as long as it does not compell someone else to provide something without consent. When someone applies for a state marriage license, she is asking the people of that state for something. While another woman may agree to apply with her, the people of the state may not agree to provide a license.


(This was originally posted at The Opine Editorials)

Friday, June 7, 2013

The Race Card and Neutering Marriage

Marriage neutering advocates frequently cite prohibitions in the past against "interracial"* marriage as why African-Americans, judges, an all who care about civil rights should support the neutering of marriage laws and the replacement of marriage with a counterfeit. The claim goes that because African-Americans in some parts of the country in the past could not marry white people, they should identify with the inability for brideless pair of a groomless pair to get a "marriage" license, and they should fight for marriage neutering.

When one takes a closer look at the situation, though, if African-Americans, as a group, have something with which to identify in this case, it is actually the denial of their voting rights. More African-Americans were denied their voting rights than were ever prevented from marrying a white person.

For example, if the pollsters are to be believed, African-Americans, as a classification, strongly supported California's Prop 22 and subsequent Prop 8, which was adopted as a state constitutional amendment. And yet their votes were cast aside by courts based on a made-up "right" and based on a demand to treat different kinds of voluntary associations as though they are the same. In other words, they were denied their voting rights in favor of imaginary rights demanded by an even smaller minority.

"Interracial" marriage has been readily recognized to be marriage by every major religion (though not all sects) all throughout history around the world. Some places in this country banned it (a true ban, as I explain below... not simply "refusing to license"). Notice that the people who passed those laws did not also set up laws to ban same-sex couples from getting married – because such a thing had never been recognized in the first place. Indeed, in the case that shot down bans on interracial marriage – Loving v. Virginia, no mention is made of same-sex couples. Same-sex "marriage" is a modern invention modeled after marriage - which was not created by the state but merely recognized by the state - but missing the key element in marriage that is of the most interest to society. This modern invention is designed for the appropriation of government benefits (already provided to domestic partners in California and other places) and public affirmation (which should be up to the public).

If marriage is about forming a microcosm of society for the sake of perpetuating it – uniting both sexes that comprise all of society, giving children both a mother and a father legally bound to each other and to them, then "interracial" marriage is the same kind of voluntary association as any other marriage. However, two men or two women, of any race, are not. Skin color is incidental to marriage, while sex is inherent to it.  Thus, the comparison to same-sex "marriage" doesn’t hold up. "Interracial" marriage is how we got new citizens like Tiger Woods. Who has ever been conceived by sodomy between two men?

Today, people are able to live their lives together without a marriage license, while in the past, property owners and employers could refuse to deal with people who were "shacking up" and cohabitation could be prosecuted. Thus, a ban on interracial marriage was a form of segregation and a denial of the freedom of association. It was truly a ban. Now, people are free to cohabitate without social or legal repercussions, and keeping the bride+groom requirement in state marriage licensing and federal law will not keep them from doing so.

Having had wrong laws regarding marriage licensing in the past does not mean that all laws regarding marriage licensing are wrong. Most people calling for marriage neutering are in favor of some form of discrimination themselves when it comes to issuing marriage licenses. Everyone involved wants some form of discrimination, such as restrictions on the number of spouses, how closely related the spouses can be, and the minimum age to to marry.

Must a brideless or groomless sex-segregating couple be treated the same as a couple integrating and uniting  both of the sexes? Why, when so many laws treat different kinds of voluntarily associations differently?

In addition to rejecting the attempt to confuse the issue with a legitimate civil rights fight from the past, the African-American community should speak up in defense of their voting rights, and judges should recognize that marriage licenses are issued on behalf of the people of a state, and the people have the power to require that marriage be integrationist rather than segregationist.

*I maintain that we are all one race – human, and this “interracial” is an artificial term in this case, in my opinion.
(I originally posted this in a slightly different form as "The Race Card and Prop 8" on my previous blog.)

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Neutering Marriage Devalues and Discourages Marriage

 ...and that is bad for children and therefore bad for society.



Some marriages are arranged. Most in our country aren't. Some are about love, some are about lust, some are about money. Some are about class. Marriage is about many things, but from a societal interest, it is – and always has been - about forming a microcosm of society for the purpose of perpetuating it. It is about joining the two sexes and providing any offspring with both a mother and a father – and that has been the universal core of marriage throughout all of human history.

In other words, licensed marriage on its most basic and level is about children.

But when laws are passed (or, in California and some other states, a court decision is issued) neutering marriage licensing, so that two men or two women can legally be designated as “married”, this is a statement that marriage, as an institution, can't be about children – because it takes both a woman and a man to make a child. Some marriages may be about children, but marriage in and of itself can't be about children - if there is a right for any two people to have a licensed marriage. Court rulings neutering marriage make the statement that licensed marriage is about feelings, or benefits, or hospital access, or any number of things that have been cited by marriage neutering activists - all of which can be addressed without a marriage license.

If marriage can't be about children, a disconnect is created in the public consciousness between marriage and raising children. Even libertarian atheist Tom Leykis, who insists that there is no benefit for a man to get married - that men can get everything they want without marriage - states that marriage benefits children. Do we really want official public policy that makes it clear that marriage is not about children?

Although we are already experiencing a significant level of illegitimacy (thanks to a disconnect between sex and marriage), divorce (thanks to a disconnect between commitment and marriage), blended families rife with jealousy, insecurity, and confusion, and a disconnect between coitus and reproduction (thanks to IVF), we still have a society that expresses that it is ideal to raise children within a marriage that created or adopted them and associates marriage with children. Except in gay circles, when someone says "We got married," one of the first questions people ask is "When do you plan on having children?" Paternity is, in many places, assigned to husbands by default when their wife births a child, even if she could have conceived the child by another man. Ex-husbands often pay child support for children that where there before he ever met their mother. Child support is expected from an ex-spouse even if the other ex-spouse is financially capable of providing for the child without assistance. Even many people who cohabitate and procreate out of wedlock get married, in large part, “for the sake of their children.”

Why?  Because children do best with a both a mother and a father, even more so if they are married to each other, and it takes both a male and a female to create children. Whether by design or as a consequence of evolution, children do best in having both that male and female parental authority as a model and with whom to bond. That child will, throughout her life, interact with both males and females. Even if you believe that our existence and the way we reproduce are sheer meaningless accidents, that socialization is important to perpetuating society in the best conditions.

Most, if not all, of the people who deny this appear to be motivated not by what is best for children or society, but what is wanted by some homosexuality advocates, fornicators, and divorced people politically and socially. Someone who wants a child but doesn't have a spouse (of the opposite sex) will try to justify their actions, and those who think a marriage license will bring their relationship and themselves whatever (approval, benefits, etc.) they are seeking will likewise deny the importance of having both a mother and father (1).

If marriage is about children, then it ought to be restricted to the kind of unions that can produce children (2). If it isn't about children, then it should be about whatever else benefits society.  Marriage neutering advocates say that purpose is creating stability in "sexual" relationships.  But that is in conflict with their own insistence that sexual behavior between two consenting adults is a private matter in which the state should not be involved.

If we are going to continue down this path of neutered marriage licensing, we should expect higher illegitimacy rates and perhaps increased divorce rates and/or lower marital rates (3), because there will be less of an association between child-rearing and marriage. If marriage is not about children, then a husband should feel no guilt in leaving the mother of his child if he feels she has neglected her vows. If our statistical analyses do not make the distinction between bride-groom marriages and other unions, then we can also expect a statistical increase in "marital" domestic violence, substance abuse, infidelity, and physical and mental health issues, as these are acknowledged issues of increased frequency in the "homosexual community". That would be something else that would make licensed marriage less attractive, along with the presence of or desire for children being less of an incentive.

If we are going to continue down this path where marriage isn't about children, then we should at least be consistent and not assign default paternity to husbands, or require child support if the custodial parent earns enough to provide for a child, or require stepparents (almost always fathers) to provide child support in the event of a divorce. This can probably have applications to inheritance laws, too.

I agree that the government should not be policing the bedroom. I can understand why we have no-fault divorce laws. But the government does have an interest in licensing bride-groom marriage that it doesn't have with same-sex couples. Citizens are better off if they have been raised within a lasting marriage with both a father and a mother, and less likely to commit crime or be dependent on welfare. We must not yield this beneficial construct to be sacrificed on the altar of homosexual esteem for those who seem to neurotically need the endorsement of their relationships by others. We must not allow marriage to be devalued by denying the core universal thread that has made marriage what it is.

Marriage may be about love, but it is primarily about children, and giving them a mother and a father.

(1) Neutered marriage licensing under the guise that same-sex couples have a “right” to marry will make it impossible for adoption agencies, social workers, fertility clinics, laws, and courts to give any preference to bride+groom couples over same-sex couples in placing children (or academia or others from presenting bride+groom couples as the norm or ideal). The advocates of this “equality” cite flawed studies to support their claim that there is no difference to children if they are raised by two men, two women, or a man and a woman, as long as it is two "parents". There are two ways to demonstrate that this must be false: A) If “two parents”, regardless of sex, are better than one, then point out that surely three parents would be preferable to two, and four preferable to three, and so forth, and ask if preference should be given to the largest group parenting arrangement over “couple parenting”, and; B) The homosexual person knows there is a difference between men and women - and therefore mothers and fathers - when it comes to personal relationships. Otherwise, the homosexual personal could just as easily be attracted to someone of the opposite sex.

(2) Yes, not all bride+groom couples choose to or can create children, but they are the only kind that can without the aid of a third party, while no same-sex couples have ever been able to create children alone. Regardless, bride+groom couples still form a microcosm of society by uniting the sexes, and we do not check fertility status of marriage license applicants as that would be a violation of privacy.  Indeed, sexual orientation is not a criterion either.

(3) The countries that have neutered their marriage licensing tend to be countries where marriages don't last as long, fewer people bother to marry, and children are more likely to be born out of wedlock. Although correlation does not prove causation, it is clear that the culture of these societies don't esteem marriage or raising children within marriage as much as ours - should we be striving to be more like them when it comes to marriage licensing? Results from marriage neutering are likely to be generational, and since no country had neutered their licensing as of 15 years ago, we have yet to fully experience the social effects.

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Professor Lund Calls Out Bogus Claims About Studies

I previously noted that there are some bogus reports on unreliable studies claiming that couples missing one of the sexes make even better parents than, you know, the kind of couple Nature or Nature's God made reproductive.

Professor Nelson Lund had a can't-miss piece in the Wall Street Journal about this. I suppose he can expect a severed unicorn's head in his bed? Or maybe lots of glitter? Maybe that savage bully fellow (hmmm.. what's his name...) could do a Google bomb on "Lund"? Oh, if the West Wing was still on, they could totally make up a character that is obviously Lund, then have the character say something Lund never said, then have the President totally knock that stawman down! But Law & Order: SVU is still on. They can make the character a pedophile or murderer. You know, all of the real honest and sensible ways of debating public policy.
The claimed right to same-sex marriage is not in the Constitution or in the court's precedents, so the court must decide whether to impose a new law making marriage into a new and different institution.
Yes. Neutering marriage replaces marriage with something else. When you take water bottles in your water bottle factory and fill some with water molecules and some only with hydrogen and some only with oxygen, you can no longer say you are selling water and be honest about it.
A significant number of organizations representing social and behavioral scientists have filed briefs promising the court that there is nothing to worry about. These assurances have no scientific foundation. Same-sex marriage is brand new, and child rearing by same-sex couples remains rare. Even if both phenomena were far more common, large amounts of data collected over decades would be required before any responsible researcher could make meaningful scientific estimates of the long-term effects of redefining marriage.
If the MNAs get their way. by the time the evidence is in, it will be too late to do anything about it.
Social-science advocacy organizations, however, have promoted the myth that a lack of evidence, so far, of bad effects implies the nonexistence of such effects. This myth is based on conjecture or faith, not science.
Science says the pairing of male and female is different from other pairings. Why is the Left suddenly anti-science?
The prominent National Longitudinal Lesbian Family Study, for instance, relied on a sample recruited entirely at lesbian events, in women's bookstores and through lesbian newspapers. Other studies relied on samples as small as 18 or 33 or 44 cases. The effect of parenting by male homosexual couples remains in the realm of anecdotes. Most research has relied on reports by parents about their children's well-being while the children were still under the care of those parents. Even a social scientist should be able to recognize that parents' evaluations of their own success as parents might be a little skewed.
No, only a bigot wouldn't take a Leftist homosexual person's opinion as absolutely factual!
There has been only one study using a large randomized sample, objective measures of well-being, and reports of grown children rather than their parents. This research, by Mark Regnerus, a sociologist at the University of Texas Austin, found that children raised in a household where a parent was involved in a same-sex romantic relationship were at a significant disadvantage with respect to a number of indicators of well being—such as depression, educational attainment and criminal behavior—compared with children of intact biological families.

One might expect this work at least to raise a caution flag, but it has been vociferously attacked on methodological grounds by the same organizations that tout the value of politically congenial research that suffers from more severe methodological shortcomings. This is what one expects from activists, not scientists.
Even science must take a dive for the sake of Leftism's drive for esteeming homosexual behaviors. Go read the whole thing.

Thursday, May 30, 2013

Bride-and-Groom is the Right Side of History

Marriage neutering advocates have taken to either feigned outrage or genuine delusions of confusion that anyone thinks that the term "marriage", when being used literally, inherently involves the union of a bride and groom. They act like such a definition for marriage, either generally or legally, is absurd. Instead, most of them insist (for now, anyway) that everything else about the definition of marriage is right – that it is a personal union[1] of two living human beings who are of age[2] and able to consent, neither of whom is currently married to others, who are not too closely[3] related to each other. It is just that the part about… you know… uniting bride & groom is wrong, according to them. So both marriage defenders and marriage neutering advocates believe that marriage is a certain kind of relationship and that other relationships are not marriage, and should not receive legal sanction as marriage.

Just try changing the definition any other way, such as asking about polygamous or incestuous marriages (which, unlike brideless or groomless pairings, have historically been recognized as actual marriages by various cultures) and most of them do everything from scoff to foam at the mouth, and insist that those are an entirely different matter from what they're talking about. So much for "consenting adults" and "love is love" and "look how long we've been together" and "we're raising kids" and "it makes people better off" and all of that. For some yet-to-be explained reason (size/power of lobby group is not a principle), the bride+groom part of definition of marriage is not inherent to marriage, but restrictions on the number or relation of the participants is... at least according to marriage neutering advocates.

Again, so both sides of this debate argue that marriage is a certain kind of relationship and that other relationships are not marriage, and should not receive legal sanction as marriage. Discrimination against those other unions is A-OK, according to what most marriage neutering advocates (currently) say.

How did marriage defenders arrive at their definition? Well, without considering any supernatural origin, every culture that has ever existed in the world for thousands of years has recognized that the union of a man and woman is different from other relationships – even cultures that celebrated homosexual behavior. Biology, sociology, and just about everyone's personal experience confirm this. History and various religions have agreed. Everyone who wrote and adopted the Constitution of the United States of America understood marriage as uniting a bride and groom. None of them is ever cited or quoted as having said that a marriage can exist without a bride or without a groom, or that there a right to have brideless or groomless unions recognized as "marriage" by the states nor the union. Every major dictionary has, historically, defined marriage as between a man and woman.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Fourteen Will Get You Twenty

Just about every young man has heard some variation of this caution against statutory rape. Having sex with a 14 year-old could land you a prison sentence of 20 years, or so the saying implies. The age of consent for sex in the USA varies by state, but I think it ranges from 18 in some states (like here in California) to 16 in some other states. In some states, parents can sign off on someone under the age of consent marrying, and statuory rape laws would no longer apply.

I have seen many Leftists, especially those who advocate the neutering of marriage, express outrage over a criminal case in Florda. Here is an Associated Press report by Kelli Kennedy.
An 18-year-old Florida cheerleader is facing felony charges that she had sexual contact with her underage, 14-year-old girlfriend, leading gay rights advocates to say the teen is being unfairly targeted for a common high school romance because she's gay.
Wrong. She's being unfairly defended because she's homosexual.
The criminal case against Kaitlyn Hunt is unusual because it involves two females, not an older male and a younger female. But advocates say older high schoolers dating their younger counterparts is an innocuous, everyday occurrence that is not prosecuted — regardless of sexual orientation — and not a crime on par with predatory sex offenses.
The law says otherwise, and we must have equal application of the law, right?
Hunt played on the basketball team with her younger girlfriend and shared the same circle of friends, said Hunt's mother, Kelley Hunt Smith. The two had a consenting relationship that began soon after Kaitlyn Hunt turned 18, and Hunt Smith said she assumed the younger girl's parents knew that.
When you're dealing with someone else's minor child, you can't assume. Oh, if only modern humans had some ability, some technologies, that would allow them communicate with each other.
Kaitlyn Hunt, who hopes to become a nurse, declined to be interviewed and is scared, her father said. However, the family has received support from all over the world, with messages coming from as far away as New Zealand, the Netherlands and Canada, Steve Hunt said. He said he reads them to her to keep her spirits up, but she feels like she has let everyone down, he said through tears.
Yeah, convicted child molestors get letters of support from all over the world, too. There was a time a parent would have been ashamed of what their child was doing in cases like this.
Prosecutors have offered a plea deal to Kaitlyn Hunt that would allow her to avoid registering as a sex offender if she pleads guilty to lesser charges of child abuse. State Attorney Bruce Colton said he would recommend two years of house arrest followed by one year probation if she takes the deal.
I wonder how many heterosexual males get that generous offer?
"One of the reasons this case has gotten people's attention is because it's being publicized as a person being persecuted because she's gay, and that has nothing to do with the case, nothing to do with the law, nothing to do with the sheriff's office filing the charges," Colton said. He said the law is designed to protect younger children from older children who might be more aggressive in starting a relationship.

"The law doesn't make any differentiation. It doesn't matter if it's two girls or two boys, or an older boy and a younger girl or an older girl and a younger boy. Whatever the combination, it doesn't matter."
Ain't equality grand?
However, gay rights advocates aren't buying that. The American Civil Liberties Union of Florida said Kaitlyn Hunt is being criminalized for behavior that "occurs every day in tens of thousands of high schools across the country, yet those other students are not facing felony convictions ... and potential lifelong branding as sex offenders."
What the ACLU is saying is that because some parents are derelict in their duty to protect their minor children, all parents should be. Because some parents let 18 year-olds do their 14 year-olds, every parent should!
Her support extends beyond the ACLU. A "Free Kate" Facebook page has generated more than 30,000 followers so far, and an online petition urging that the charges be dropped crashed at one point because it got so much traffic. It now has more than 100,000 signatures. And during a press conference Monday, dozens of supporters showed up outside of the Indian River Sheriff's Department, many wearing T-Shirts that read "Stop the Hate, Free Kate" with rainbow hearts.
All of these people  apparentlysupport statutory rape. Remeber this the next time someone experesses outrage that someone else seems to be linking homosexuality advocacy with pedophilia.
The family said Kaitlyn Hunt had been demonized by some, and they disabled her personal Facebook account to protect her from negative comments. At school in February, her 17-year-old sister spent a half-hour cleaning a mirror where someone had written a slur against women and other words including "rapist" and "disgusting," Steve Hunt said.
Is that all? That's rather tame.

Is there any reason why a Kaitlyn Hunt shouldn't be prosecuted as strongly as a Mike Hunt for having sex with a girl?

Never forget that ACLU and other groups are spending time, money, and effort trying to decriminalize an adult having sex with a 14 year-old.

Monday, May 20, 2013

Every Child Naturally Has a Mother and a Father

A short but sweet video defending the bride+groom requirement:

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

Deftly Defending DOMA

The fate of the federal Defense of Marriage Act, signed into law by Democrat President Bill Clinton with the backing of both Democrats and Republicans before any state had neutered marriage licensing, is currently in the hands of the Supreme Court of the United States.

Some conservatives reject the Constitutionality of DOMA based on federalism, which some of the Left have cited as well, inconsistent with most of their positions. I support federalism, too, but as we'll see below that doesn't mean DOMA is unconstitutional. I have wondered ever since DOMA has been an issue if, because some states mess things up, everyone else should be forced go along, especially given that there are many examples of states issuing other licenses and other legal designations that other states don't have to accept. A neutered license is no longer a "marriage" license, it is a "two people who are not legally married to others, of age, and not too closely related" license, and as such, should states be forced to recognize them?

I don't know of any legal analysts who expect such a move, nor do I think any notable briefs submitted to SCOTUS call for it, but although I recognize that certain powers are reserved to the state, I do think it is possible a credible case could be made that the right of a child to a mother and father could justify federal involvement in restoring bride+groom requirements to state marriage licenses.

For now, though, let's see what some others have said about why DOMA does pass the Constitutional test.

Saturday, May 11, 2013

Paradox Now – Marriage Neutering and Gender Distinctions

Marriage neutering activists seem indignant when I write that their position degrades masculinity and femininity. Yet, discuss the issues with them for any length of time, and they prove my point for me by insisting that there really is no significant difference between men and women.

What’s even more interesting to note is that these very people who insist there really is no significant difference between men and woman swear they could not share their lives with someone of the opposite sex, and so bride+groom marriage licensing excludes them by virtue of their inability to desire or enjoy a life with someone of the opposite sex.

So... there is a big enough difference when it comes to their choice in life partners – but not a big enough difference to make a sex-integrated union different from a sex-segregated union, or to matter to a child?

This is the crowd that claims to be all for diversity, but doesn’t think it is important for marriage to have the diversity of both sexes or a child to have the diversity in their own home of a mother and a father.

The demand for the neutering of marriage is built on the mutually exclusive claims that men and women are interchangeable and that men and women are not interchangeable, and thus is bankrupt. The hope of the marriage neutering advocate rests in appeals to emotion.

Neutering Marriage is Not a Conservative Position

 blogs "Hey gay people! you're being used".

And it's not about rights, either the rights of gay people to get "married" (according to the new definition) or about the rights of religious people to "freedom of worship".

It's about the state increasing its power.

"The central problem with the gay marriage agenda is not that at some point in the future an unwilling man of the cloth might be strongarmed into giving his blessing to a gay union, but rather that it allows the state to do something that was traditionally considered beyond its purview…

Some have sought to depict the drive for gay marriage as a continuation of the struggle for civil rights that exploded in the mid-twentieth century; it’s better understood as a continuation, and intensification, of the modern state’s desire to get a foot in the door of our private lives and to assume sovereignty over our relationships."

More here, here, and here.
Expanding government intrusion into personal relationships and families is not a good thing.

Friday, May 10, 2013

Elizabeth Warren Can’t See the Forest Through the Trees Planted by Capitalists

Elizabeth Warren certainly is popular with my Leftist connections on Facebook. They proudly copy and pasted her comments:
I hear all this, you know, 'Well, this is class warfare, this is whatever. No.

Yes, it is class warfare to target the "rich" – by definition.
There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own -- nobody.

Well, no, there isn't, because someone else has to buy the good and services provided by the rich. The fact is, nobody really does ANYTHING on their own, but we still need to have boundaries. There still needs to be some level of personal autonomy, private property and ownership, and personal responsibility. Should Warren be elected to Senate, she will not have done it on her own, yet she will not be forced to let more than a third of her votes be cast by someone else.
You built a factory out there? Good for you. But I want to be clear. You moved your goods to market on the roads the rest of us paid for.

The rich paid for those roads, too. All of us - who buy gas, anyway - paid for those roads, all of us can use them. Even the people who don't buy gas.
You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate.

Property owners, a group which definitely includes the rich, paid to educate them. But I'm for separation of state and school anyway.
You were safe in your factory because of police-forces and fire-forces that the rest of us paid for.

Again, the rich pay for them, too – more so than other people.
You didn't have to worry that marauding bands would come and seize everything at your factory -- and hire someone to protect against this -- because of the work the rest of us did.

Uh, is there a factory that doesn't have private security?
Now look, you built a factory and it turned into something terrific, or a great idea. God bless -- keep a big hunk of it. But part of the underlying social contract is, you take a hunk of that and pay forward for the next kid who comes along.

And why does that have to be through the hands of D.C. politicians? Who is it that is funding charities, anyway?

No doubt unwittingly, Elizabeth Warren actually makes our point for us – that by letting free markets work, people who build wealth employ other people to mutual benefit. The wealthy got wealthy, in part, through providing jobs.

The people the wealthy hired were compensated as agreed. The customers who bought the goods or services provided by the wealthy were given that for which they paid. Now, people like Warren want to ignore the fact that the mutual, voluntary transactions were completed and use government force to make the wealthy pay more not only to those already compensated for their work, but to uninvolved people who refuse to work at all.

Are we to believe that someone who studied hard and stayed clean and involved through high school, college, and medical school to become a doctor and works long and odd hours saving lives and then practices good financial habits has less right to enjoy the fruits of her labors and risks than someone who goofed off, dropped out, abused substances, caused trouble, watches the clock at his entry-level job to make sure that he never appears to be working a minute more than 40 hours per week (minus breaks), and blows his money?

All of the things Warren lists have been available to all. It is the wealthy that used them in ways valued most by society.

You can find some good responses to Warren here, here, and here.

Monday, May 6, 2013

A Test For Marriage Neutering Advocates

Rhode Island became the most recent state to neuter its marriage licensing.

Rhode Island has no existing laws whatsoever against consensual incest.

Based on these facts (and you can check them out for yourself if you don't believe me) I'd like to know from marriage neutering advocates what their reaction would be to this situation:

Two unmarried women approach the counter at the appropriate government office in Rhode Island and ask for a license, saying "We very much want to get married." They have been living together for many years now, and are raising two children together. The clerk examines the paperwork and realizes that the women share a biological father, who has never been in either's life. As it turns out, the women were not raised together and only met for the first time as adults.

Should the law instruct the clerk to issue them a state-recognized license, entitling them to all of the legal aspects of marriage?

If not, why not? Is it Constitutional to deny them a license?

Remember, their relationship is not criminal in any way.

Saturday, May 4, 2013

Greg Koukl on Secular Religious Division of Marriage

Greg Koukl of Stand to Reason on "Can Marriage Be Divided into Secular and Religious Institutions?"

The Left and Moral Equivalence

I like getting the perspective of Tammy Bruce and her friends. Tammy has been a voice for audio content for a long time. She also writes books and columns, blogs, and appeared on cable news as a talking head. Shifra blogged on Tammy's site something called "Liberals and Moral Equivalence".
First, some definitions of terms, as “moral relativism” and “moral equivalence,” are, it seems, sometimes used interchangeably. But, while related, they are, in fact, different.

“Moral relativism” refers to the notion that, in our diverse, multicultural world, no one culture is better than another culture, so that no judgments can be made about a specific culture.

For example:

In the U.S.A., a day off may be spent having a picnic with family and friends, enjoying a barbecue, tossing a Frisbee, or maybe catching a ball game, while, in some Islamic countries, a day off might entail having the village gather to watch a woman being shoved waist-deep into a hole in the ground, while everyone throws boulders until she is stoned to death, all because she is suspected of having committed adultery.

See? Different strokes for different folks.

In The New Thought Police, Tammy wrote about the danger of such a world-view:
Multiculturalism is not about exotic restaurants and charming street fairs. It is a code word for moral relativism. Accepting the notion that all ideas and systems are equal precludes a willingness to think critically about what surrounds us. It is the cornerstone of our inability to come to judgments about events…. (p. 150)
Moral equivalence, on the other hand, is a deceptive device used by Liberals to “prove” their points by taking the focus away from the obvious evil, and focusing on what they  perceive to be the more “immediate problem.”
Go read her examples of moral equivalence.

Leftists do not have to be consistent or coherent, have priorities or perspective, because their whole way of looking at things is based on feeling and emotion.

Also, a question I like to ask partisans is, "If the other party's guy/gal did what you party's guy/gal just did, would you think that is OK?" I'm not necessarily talking about taking a position, but about the principles or actions. For example, is filibustering OK or not? That sort of thing.

Friday, May 3, 2013

David Russell Explains Marriage Defense Well

David Russell writes at The Poached Egg on his case for marriage. He touches upon what's going on in Christian circles:
One Man One Woman
We live in a culture where sensationalism wins the day and scriptural illiteracy runs rampant in the pews. To assume Christ would change his mind undermines the truth of his divinity and if the apostles got it wrong the inerrant word of God is no longer inerrant or it is basically ignored. The scriptures couldn't be more true when it says, "My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge." (Hosea 4:6)


 
One need not be Christian to see that marriage unites the sexes, but any follow of Christ should not deny what He affirmed. Then Russell moves on to the larger issue of society:
 
Civil rights is not the issue. There is no discrimination except in basic behavior, which all laws are based around. The truth is, we are all entitled to marry in the same way, we all share the same rights and restrictions equally. I am a heterosexual male and have the same right to marry as the homosexual, I also have the same restrictions the homosexual has. Greg Koukl gives a beautiful illustration in a past issue of solid ground, he puts it like this, “Smith and Jones both qualify to vote in America where they are citizens. Neither are allowed to vote in France. Jones, however has no interest in U.S. politics, he's partial to European concerns. Would Jones have a case if he complained?" Simply put NO! both he and Smith have the same rights to vote in America Smith chooses to exercise that right, so for Jones there is only inequality in desire not in legality. 
Basically, the marriage law applies to each citizen in exactly the same way, the Homosexual wants the right to do something neither person can do. So all those with equal signs posted to their profiles are drastically misinformed, or they simply like being part of the crowd.
Right. Heterosexuals and homosexuals have EQUAL rights now, and they would still have them under neutered licensing. This is not about equality, but that word is a useful emotional hook.

Natural marriage produces the next generation, the government has a vested interest in the next generation, so, naturally it promotes the carrying on of the civilization. The government needs to be somewhat involved in this process due to the behavior of humans and their inability to commit. Also, imagine what a man would do if there was no accountability, he could leave and bear no responsibility to his mate or children; the government makes sure the women and children are protected. The government doesn't get involved because you're in love, it reigns in that aspect of commitment and furthermore, deals with inheritance intrinsic to natural marriage, It also provides relief to promote the family in regard to the very nature of child rearing, something also inherent to natural marriage. Tax relief is given to lighten the load for fathers who have out of work mothers and children you now have to feed.
That is a excellent way of boiling down the truth of the matter.

With examining the benefits of natural marriage, why do I think it should be the only one promoted by government? First, it is the natural foundation of society and yields benefits to everyone, no other relationship can do that. Second, a study by J.D. Unwin concludes out of eighty six civilizations spanning the course of five thousand years the most prosperous were the ones with a strong marriage ethic, he includes that every civilization that abandoned this ethic and liberalized their sexual practices experienced demise not long after. (Joseph Unwin, Sex and Culture: London Oxford press, 1934)
I'm sure some Leftist has written a response to that work by now that blames economic inequality for the demise of those civilizations.

Is Jesus a Republican?

My short answer is "no".

But he certainly isn't a Democrat, either.

The GOP is a U.S. political party, and as such, is a man-made organization, the main purpose of which is to get members elected and appointed to government offices. It is a flawed organization founded and comprised of flawed people.

I do believe, though, that conservatism can be consistent with Christian principles, and in fact I maintain that my own conservatism is consistent with my Christian worldview. And, in the U.S., it is the GOP that is a home to the conservative movement and is one of the two dominant, effective political parties, hence my support for the GOP.

In an ideal situation, the perfect form of government is a benevolent dictatorship - an absolute monarchy, actually – with the monarch being eternal, unchanging, unequaled, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, holy, loving, merciful, and just. (That’s God, to those of you who are slow on the uptake.) But since He has given us the freedom to govern ourselves for now, and we are a mix of unrepentant sinners and repentant-but-still-unperfected sinners, I do not believe there is a better governmental system than the brilliant one devised by our mostly Christian-influenced founders – our union of states in a capitalist, constitutional, democratic, representative, republic with separation of powers and checks and balances.

It is that system that recognizes that people will generally look out for their own self-interests and in doing so will cooperate where mutually beneficial, and will also engage voluntarily in private charity. It is that system that recognizes that since sin has marred each of us, none of us should have too much power. It is that system that recognizes that people will do wrong, and some of those wrongs demand a collective response from the people as a whole. So, it is a system that understands that true nature of people.

This is a system worth conserving.  Hence - conservatism.

Conservatism generally (if not all individual conservatives) promotes respect for human life; defending and esteeming marriage; respect for authority; personal freedom, responsibility and accountability; punishment and restitution for wrongs; private charity; and encourages acknowledging God in all areas of life. These are all very much part of what Jesus taught and affirmed.

Leftists, including some Democrats, cite God as Creator and Jesus' acceptance of prostitutes and others marginalized by society during his earthly ministry, His message of forgiveness, His "cast the first stone" and "take the plank out of your own eye" statements, His commands to take care of the needy, His "turn the other cheek" statement, and His willingness to be beaten and crucified as examples of why Republicans and conservatives are wrong and why Christians should support Democrats in their efforts to:

-expand government social spending (including allowing illegal aliens to come here, stay here, and receive such spending)

-socialize health care

-implement "environmental protection" legislation that is really about forced wealth transfer and infringing on private property rights

-promote pacifism

-promote licentiousness, especially in sexual behavior

Such applications take Jesus' words and actions out of context and twist His words.

It is bizarre to me that people who so stridently promote and defend philosophical naturalism (claiming that we and everything else in the universe are the products of nothing more than natural processes alone) appeal to our belief in a Creator to promote their "environmental protection" agenda. Many of these people are the same people that see nothing wrong with dismembering babies in the womb. Many of the same people who promote government-funded (meaning taxpayer-funded) health care for seniors by appealing to our compassion would just as soon put our seniors to death, claiming it is for dignity and pain-relief, but in actuality because the seniors would become an expensive inconvenience.

Yes, Jesus accepted and forgave people who admitted and repented of their sins. You can't repent of sins if you don't recognize them as sins in the first place. The phrase "Go and sin no more" comes to mind. He saved their souls but did not necessarily protect them from the earthly consequences of their sins. The repentant thief on the cross comes to mind – Jesus told him "Today, you will be with me in Paradise," indicating he was forgiven, but Jesus didn't use His power to remove the man from the cross and stave off death.  And yes, people should take the plank out of their own eye before trying to remove the speck in someone else's eye, and if you have repented of your sins and turned to Jesus, then the plank has been removed.

He'll judge the world in the future, but Jesus certainly wasn't "nonjudgmental" during His earthly ministry.  According to the written accounts of His teachings, He talked a lot about Hell and had some choice words in public for certain people, and don't forget what He did to the money changers.

Jesus ordered His followers to take care of the poor, not the government. He didn't advocate stealing from the rich to "care for the poor".  He told a rich man to sell everything he had and give it to the poor himself, not to sell all he had and give it to Rome for redistribution.

Jesus did not teach pacifism, either.  As Greg Koukl points out, "turning the other cheek" likely refers to dealing with insults. Jesus sent His disciples out with swords. I'd agree that Jesus would be against using force unjustly, but not all use of force is unjust.

(Oh - and despite what PETA would say, Jesus was not a vegetarian, either.)

I'd like to note that nowhere does Jesus command us to spread Christianity by force. He commanded us to make disciples, true, but everything about His earthly ministry teaches us to make disciples by preaching the Gospel through our words and living the Gospel in our actions. Promote clean living. Care for those in need, including telling them when, where, and how their sins are causing their problems (IF their own sins are causing those particular problems).

So, while I wouldn't say that Jesus is a Republican, I would say that being a Republican is entirely compatible with being a Christian. Being a Christian is much more than just being involved in politics, however. It also includes living a moral life and giving of your time, talent, and treasure to those who need it. We can't insist that the government get out of social spending and then not pick up the slack ourselves by tending to the legitimate needs of others. That is all part of having a relationship with Christ as your Lord and Savior.

Sunday, April 28, 2013

The Bush Legacy

I wrote on January 20, 2009:

= = =
It is impossible to write a definitive judgment on the legacy of President George W. Bush at this time, although there have been many evaluations and retrospectives in the last several months.

Left-leaning folks, especially those who have had Bush Derangement Syndrome from the moment the first chad dangled, will try to blame him as much as possible while denying him as much credit as they can, and some Republicans will defend Bush's every move, even if they would have pitched a fit if it had been done by a Democrat.

We should be vigilant against those who would try to write him into history as the worst President ever. They will try to do so for political expediency, since he is the most recent Republican to serve in that office, and the only President besides Obama that most newer voters will remember with any understanding.

We should also be careful not to let Bush's decisions or tolerations that were decidedly expansive of government be portrayed as proof that limiting government doesn't work.